Folks, the problem I reported over the last few days where groups on the DC
had no effect on my workstation has been (sort of) solved, more accurately
it has been circumvented. I hope you don't mind if this is on-topic for the
group as it might be of general use.

 

A friend who is a network administrator kindly took time to drop in an
examine the problem. Methodically using different domain accounts, different
groups, different group memberships, many logoffs and reboots we determined
that the problem only exists for my domain account named 'greg'. All other
domain users behaved correctly and honoured group and membership changes on
the DC.

 

The first experiment was to utterly remove account 'greg' from everywhere
and leave the domain. I then recreated 'greg' and rejoined the domain, but
the problem returned. This proved that there is something internally
"corrupt" with that specific account name. I can't tell where this
corruption is or who to blame for it. I created a brand new account 'gregk'
and it is behaving correctly. The solution is to therefore simply abandon
using the account name 'greg' which has become permanently unusable for some
unknown reason.

 

I discovered one other surprising thing during this exercise: Group and
membership changes on the Win2008 R2 DC do not immediately propagate out to
my Win7 workstation. I'm surprised because on my old Win2003 DC the changes
were immediately effective. A logoff+login is supposed to create a new
token, but I find that DC changes are not picked up this way. I find I have
reboot+login Win7 to pick up the changes. This seems like a step backwards,
but it's only a minor irritation.

 

So there you go, the problem is basically intractable and I had to
circumvent it.

 

Greg

Reply via email to