>>>>> Miles Fidelman <[email protected]> writes:
>>>>> Ivan Shmakov wrote:

[…]

 >>> A URI into a DHT is really for local consumption only - it's a key
 >>> into the local code that executes the DHT's algorithm, rather than
 >>> an identifier that can be used across the net.

 >> I don't quite understand what is meant by “[a] URI into a DHT”, but
 >> the URN's I'm interested in are perfectly suitable for
 >> communication, be it in writing, e-mail, or World Wide Web.

[…]

 > What I mean is that

 > gnunet://fs/sks/TU6GGH9COPQLPQTG919BB0QVEVIO1SF1IRGI7ACBGOHKVPNCGRUQG98H4DTTPDNDVMV83E8SI51GR66AL6S47BLLK4LULR8J1A7T188/ivan

 > requires that you have the gnunet software installed,

        It's pretty much the same as for urn:ietf:std:66, or even
        http://example.org/ — is the latter of any use if there's no
        HTTP client on the host in question?

 > and generally you are typing that URL into the gnunet software.

        Indeed, the majority of the World Wide Web software currently in
        use supports only a tiny fraction of the URI schemes currently
        registered.  My guess is that this particular case is in the
        GNUnet project TODO list, though.

 > It's not like there's a gnunet protocol and API that is generally
 > accessible across the net.  This is simply a representation of a
 > gnunet DHT key.

        Not quite.  While GNUnet may use such an identifier as a key for
        its DHT, it's possible to compute it for a given file
        independently of GNUnet (for the purposes of validation, or
        otherwise.)

        While rhash(1) doesn't seem to support GNUnet CHK's (TODO?), it
        computes BitTorrent infohashes just fine.  Consider, e. g.:

$ rhash --simple --btih -- hello 
aa95e34e2f7eac67d73ff479c135d5a75d2c8412  hello
$ 

        Thus, it's already possible to use BitTorrent infohashes
        independently of any BitTorrent agent software whatsoever.  The
        same should apply to the content-derived identifiers employed by
        the other “file-sharing” P2P networks just as well.

-- 
FSF associate member #7257      np. face_another_day.mod

_______________________________________________
p2p-hackers mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.zooko.com/mailman/listinfo/p2p-hackers

Reply via email to