-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 On 02/20/2012 06:20 PM, Michael Chen wrote: > Hi, > > We are painfully aware of many meaningless and bad designs in the draft > being kept by firm hands of key members of this group, often citing "not to > break existing implementations out there". > > Well, where are these existing implementation "out there"? Why aren't they > participate in the inter-op?
That a very good point. > > Cisco, Polycom, Skype, Huawei, anyone? > > Can we predict that couple years from now we all have to implement known > bugs in order to inter-operate with Cisco phones or Polycom intercom "out > there"? Yes, and the sad part is that there is a mechanism in RELOAD to cope with early implementations: Just increment the version number each time a new I-D breaks interoperability (This is exactly what hyby did for Websockets, which seems to work very well). And BTW, when published as RFC, the RELOAD version *will* increment to 0x10, which means that none of the early implementations will work with this version anyway. > > Thank you > > Michael Chen > > -----Original message----- > > *From: *Marc Petit-Huguenin <[email protected]>* To: *[email protected]* Cc: > *[email protected]* Sent: *Mon, Feb 20, 2012 18:18:18 GMT+00:00* > Subject: *Re: [P2PSIP] [reload-implementers] RELOAD testing at IETF83 > > I did not see much interest in the RELOAD interop in Paris so far. If you > think that you will maybe attend, please send me a direct email, you will > be able to cancel without problem. I really need to have an idea of the > number of people attending for planning purpose. - -- Marc Petit-Huguenin Personal email: [email protected] Professional email: [email protected] Blog: http://blog.marc.petit-huguenin.org -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux) iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJPQ8uHAAoJECnERZXWan7EnwMQANcXQMdEapCn4/yGnv7xHOgD nBq+K7ReKkhUclRXWofoMRm2WTenG3Ubeh5SxM3OApDlQI18lD/LXUTMqw9kzx+z FeS5x7U8j6poVL605isog+FAI+39o1+fivd8WwBAEnVZRw+Y7EOoc/wuKPKwWXSr 5G1sb5l2ZCzSNg6xH8FdXt5JdcKhJzq87KHaF4DtLs3/4Cy4UVFZWlkXki35s5d8 /uPWcIgaUt8y/eKUsZOgY4gVMON4DBbugzKBtlnN+mLL4A16ajYz6L+OPnnnFWEU Lnek9krFIbYuZfdFS1JHGpjm01G0IFDPUWox+vQBmhlT+D/HQ33+KLGywknqCEOi iYpwz7hs6K996iDzpdcubbAUgLfqYFqwd7Gokt3pAPQVOq0zTqR8nOGorR9rvMV6 wRIuYChY2bcnXxBJtbVu3fJKRkRX0UBTB2Ed/oDIv+TsGbNC7bp8XyMvSRtaJji/ 4J/3Twi5JVqnxAI1vQMz70c1/q0aePDJmGknArgkLOyMN7ap5hcsUjnNsvOiN0k5 G0DrqvGZbYjGCY4MrstDYJRUZ8SHyI+wIJSw16s/GVwwPVknhyLxra/FJ1NvnX4A K2z2uZNY/hazRZVUS5gU6NpCrX1RbcEQSJkNijrd72NVxZEhORYronXQDSf9nRlG lY6D6yhX8aNOcbWkgI0v =XoR7 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ P2PSIP mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/p2psip
