Manon:

Replacing MS NPS with PacketFence is similar to replacing a Segway scooter with 
a Tesla roadster.

Sure, they both get you around, but one gets you a lot farther than the other.

NPS is essentially RADIUS with a Microsoft front-end.

A better 1:1 replacement would be FreeRADIUS, which is a piece of the 
technology stack used by PacketFence. However FreeRADIUS is perfectly happy to 
run in a standalone environment.

If all you're looking for is RADIUS, PF is probably overkill. PF comes into 
play when you want to establish complete Network Access Control and not just 
AAA.

Also, FreeRADIUS plugs into Kea DHCP quite easily if that is something you need.

Good luck to you!


Jake Sallee

MANAGER OF INFORMATION SECURITY AND NETWORKS

UMHB Box 8005 | 900 College Street | Belton, Texas 76513

Phone: 254.295.4658 Fax: 254-295-4221

umhb.edu<http://www.umhb.edu/> [cid:[email protected]] 
<http://facebook.com/umhb>     [cid:[email protected]] 
<http://instagram.com/umhb>     [cid:[email protected]] 
<http://twitter.com/umhb>

[ESig_UMHB_Primary_4CP_Purple]

________________________________
From: M Anon via PacketFence-users <[email protected]>
Sent: Wednesday, November 4, 2026 4:05 AM
To: [email protected] 
<[email protected]>
Cc: M Anon <[email protected]>
Subject: [PacketFence-users] NPS replacement

EXTERNAL Exercise Caution
Hi,

I am looking at replacements for NPS and PacketFence came up. There's no 
mention of redundancy / failover that I could find in the docs except the 
clustering configuration. I don't want the hassle of clusters and just need it 
to behave like NPS where the network devices handle the redundancy / failover. 
Is it possible to have 2 standalone instances of PF (on different subnets) and 
have it work like NPS?

I'm also wary of the fact that the doc says it needs to be "aware of the 
equipment it manages". Does this mean I have to register all network switches 
to it? Again, here I'd like for it to function similar to NPS (I didn't have to 
register any switches).

It also installs its own DHCP apparently. I assume this can be disabled (we use 
ISC KEA)?

Any advise is welcome.

Manon
_______________________________________________
PacketFence-users mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/packetfence-users

Reply via email to