Hi Loa, > Comment: > > 5.2. PCEP-Error Object > > IANA is requested to register the following error types and error > values within the "PCEP-ERROR Object Error Types and Values" > subregistry of the "Path Computation Element Protocol (PCEP) Numbers" > registry: > > +--------------+-------------------------------------+ > | Error-Type | Meaning | > +--------------+-------------------------------------+ > | 6 | Mandatory Object missing | > | | Error-value | > | | TBD2: LSP-EXTENDED-FLAG TLV missing | > +--------------+-------------------------------------+ > > Table 2 > > Both the RTG DIR rules and IANA rules strongly advice against putting > fixed numeric values into allocation from existing registries. The > reason is obvious, in the time from you put the value in your document > until iet is ready for IESG review (which includes IANA review) someone > else might have been assigned tht value. This has happened and have > caused serious problems. > > 6 in table 2 hould be replaced with TBA (to be assigned). > > Note: If you really want the value 6, we should go for an early > allocation as soon as we have the wg document. >
[Dhruv] The value 6 is for Error-Type already allocated by RFC 5440. This I-D is asking for a new Error-Value which is TBD2. A reference column in the IANA table would have helped here. > Question: > > In section 4 you say: > > The LSP-EXTENDED-FLAG TLV MUST be defined as mandatory when a router > supporting the LSP Object and needs to use the extended flag field. > > I don't really parse; are you saying that if it is present it should be > treated as mandatory? > > If that is what you are saying, what does it change? > [Dhruv]: I read it as a requirement for a future extension that would define a flag in the LSP-EXTENDED-FLAG TLV. If that is true, I would suggest not using normative MUST. How about - A future extension that defines a flag in the LSP-EXTENDED-FLAG TLV could mark this TLV as mandatory to be carried the LSP Object. Thanks! Dhruv > /Loa > > > -- > > Loa Andersson email: [email protected] > Senior MPLS Expert [email protected] > Bronze Dragon Consulting phone: +46 739 81 21 64 _______________________________________________ Pce mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce
