On 2010-06-29 13:45, João Pais wrote: > > well, how often do you use click tracks? do you have many pieces for > instruments + conductor with complex metrics, and/or tempi changing at > each bar e.g. as in the music of Ferneyhough, Emmanuel Nunes, Carter... > are you familiar with these composers? > the patch is available in my pd page for more than a year now, did you > look at it?
what are you trying to say with this (apart from offending people's musical background)? > > I'm just being realistic, it's not a value judgement. If I had made a > nice vocoder with online streaming, that would be much more interesting > for this community. > what's this nonsense about being "realistic"? on which grounds do you build your reality? what's this nonsense about "this community"? what makes you think that this community prefers phase-vocoders over compositional structures? the available help-patches? the fact that there are few orchestral pieces presented at Pd-conventions? i've been publishing software for years now, and i never tried to be "realistic" before publishing it. some of this software has been successfull (and is used by a lot of people; iirc, your click-tracker uses some of my objects) and other has not. pretty all of my code is highly domain-specific, and thus probably not very appealing to you (are you interested in matrix maths? in graphics? in click-tracks? in live-coding? in 3d-sound? in website rendering?). still some of these domain specific things have found there comunity. what i want to say is that you should not make assumptions about people whom you don't know at all. mfgadr IOhannes PS: funnily, i have been helping a bit with a click-track system for 35 independent (click-track wise) voices, using a Pd object i never thought about in the context of click-track. PPS: for what it is worth: i cannot remember you announcing anything about your click-track patch in the past; even so, the webserver-logs show that it has been downloaded about once per week. i don't think this justifies as being totally unrealistic.
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
_______________________________________________ [email protected] mailing list UNSUBSCRIBE and account-management -> http://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-list
