Boris, 
FWIW, if you ask for a critique, take it, digest it, learn from it if possible, but 
don't defend it - you're asking for someone's opinion. If they solicit an answer to 
some aspect of the image then give it.
My $.02 worth.
It's no rule.

Ken Waller

-----Original Message-----
From: Boris Liberman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Subject: Re: PAE #?

Hi!

TMP> The tree to the left looks a bit strange due to it actually being taller
TMP> than the skyscrapers, for me, it puts the perspective out a little.  Maybe
TMP> (I'm not sure where you were standing), you could have moved a little more
TMP> to the right to not include the tree in the frame?  Just by changing the
TMP> angle, you should still have been able to keep all of the sunset and the
TMP> rays, cityscape etc in the frame...  Although then the light may have been
TMP> coming through the clouds differently...  I have no idea, just ignore me, I
TMP> am thinking out loud and talking rubbish, I fear! lol...

Tanya, with all due respect, I do think that the tree actually makes
the shot. Which I wrote in my comments I believe. It is light, tree
and city - three components, not less.

I hope I am not breaking any rules here by countering someone else's
opinion... If I do, I apologize in advance.

Boris




PeoplePC Online
A better way to Internet
http://www.peoplepc.com

Reply via email to