I deem everything you justy said nonsense!! Weee this is fun!!

-Shawn

-----Original Message-----
From: Cotty [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Friday, May 14, 2004 5:58 PM
To: pentax list
Subject: RE: Street Photography ... A Stranger a Day




>I definitely don't understand why it would be called "nonsense".

The guy has a style, I don't like it. Chopping off the tops of heads does
nothing for me - it was done on purpose, not by accident (I assume?) - it
was presented as as such, and so at the wishes of the photographer. He
had control. I find it irritating, so I don't look.

Nothing new in photography, it's all been done before. Placing people on
the edges of frame, or just having bits of them, or not quite all of
them, or whatever. I would have preferred to see the subjects without
heads chopped, in an honest and straightforward manor, yes traditional,
but that's me.

When I see a portrait like some of those shown, with heads chopped off,
or tops of heads cropped, I wonder why, but can't make any sense of why
it would have been done, because the only person I can relate to is
myself, in that situation. I ask myself, 'Self (for it is me), would you
chop off a head?' And I reply, 'No, Self, I would not'. Therefore, it
makes no sense to me, and ipso facto it becomes nonesensical to me, and
therefore I deem it nonesense.


Cheers,
  Cotty

Favourite portrait photographer: Arnold Newman.


___/\__
||   (O)   |     People, Places, Pastiche
||=====|    www.macads.co.uk/snaps
_____________________________


Reply via email to