I haven't run into this problem, as far as I can tell, with my SMC-F 70-210. I have consistently enjoyed the results from this lens.

Here's a handheld shot at 210mm (exposure was 1/750, I believe, aperture closed down a bit from wide open). Camera was PZ-1p.

http://homepage.mac.com/wilensky/Stilts_1.jpg
Uncropped, about 380K.

Joe


Hi Tom!

At last, I've probably understood the issue of the F 70-210 quality.

I was wrong when thinking the lens is a dog at longer focal lengths.
(because if you focus carefully, performance is good)

I was right when thinking the lens is a dog at longer focal lengths.
(because if you shoot AF, as one could expect from such an AF lens,
performance can be very bad)

The problem is the lens tends to focus on a plane closer than the subject
you autofocus on!
As somebody may recall, I found that same problem with the FA* 1.4/85mm,
another lens somebody thinks to be excellent (me included) while somebody
else thinks to be bad.

I found that problem some time ago, by using the FA* 85/1.4 on my MZ-S,
while now the F 70-210 does the same on my *ist D. Other lenses on those
same cameras autofocus very well, including my brand new Sigma 2.8/70-210
EX.

I cannot explain such an odd behaviour, since AF is performed by the camera,
and that same camera apparently shows problems with above lenses only.

A revised test shot series of the F 70-210, compared to the Takumar 3.5/200
and the Sigma, is here:

http://www.dariobonazza.com/t04p13e.htm
(it might take some time to load the heavy page)

Dario Bonazza




Reply via email to