The colour version is definitely a great shot - I'm torn between Shel's brighter (less contrasty?) version, and John's original dark one. The tighter crop also darkens the mood a bit, it seems to me. The B&W is good, but loses some of the punch for me. All in all, a beautiful shot to my untrained eye.
jp >From: Cotty [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] >Sent: Thursday, April 21, 2005 10:20 AM > >On 21/4/05, Shel Belinkoff, discombobulated, unleashed: > >>The color version is much better than the B&W, but I think >you cropped >>the pic way too much. My thought was to correct the perspective and >>just trim the photo a bit to compemsate for the tilt. >> >>http://home.earthlink.net/~my-pics/straighten.jpg > >Actually, seeing John's and Shel's crops side by side, I have >to agree with Shel. The loose crop gives it more atmosphere IMO. > >HTH --------------------------- Jon Paul Schelter - Programmer, Rockstar Games Toronto http://home.eol.ca/~snark/
