On 24 May 2005 at 17:12, Tom C wrote:

> Hi Rob,
> 
> But for the larger sizes, microdrives are 1/3 to 1/4 the cost of CF.

Not now, check prices, 1/2 where I buy, the peace of mind is worth it.

> I don't care that a microdrive may be a second or so slower than a CF card. 
> It's usually many seconds or minutes before I'm taking the next shot.  With 
> the
> *ist D's small buffer, if I was shooting in rapid succession, I'd fill up the
> buffer and be waiting awhile anyway, to get the next shot off.

The buffer takes quite a bit longer to empty to the MD, I've never really 
noticed a difference between SS CF cards but the MD I did.

> I haven't noticed a huge battery drain with a microdrive... I haven't paid 
> much
> attention, but I would think that the power drain would need to be significant
> for a casual observer to notice it.

I used to get half the transfer capacity in the field using my X-S Drive, MD 
use quite a lot more power than SS CF cards.

> I've had the 1GB microdrive for 3+ years.  Never a problem.   I carry 
> laptops on a daily basis and with their huge hard drives, have only had 1 
> fail once in 7 years.

The difference between the drive in your lap-top is that it is mechanically 
isolated to a far larger extent, same as my 80GB drive in my external storage 
unit. Something relatively hugh and expensive is far less likely to be 
inadvertently mishandled. I've had quite a few occasions where I've lost grip 
on my CF cards and they've slapped on the table or fallen to the ground in a 
bumping crowd, they have survived and I have complete confidence in them. If a 
MD had have been inadvertently subjected to the same mistreatment I'm sure it 
would have been toast.

> The microdrives are, IMO, an inexpensive, well engineered device, that are 
> good
> for their intended purpose.  It's not like using CF is a guarantee against
> disaster, and using a microdrive is asking for it.

Built into a bigger device I can see the advantage but used as a removable card 
I can't justify using one.

> I might not advocate using microdrives exclusively, but having a couple as
> inexpensive alternatives to CF is not a bad way to go.

I'll be fine from now on with 2 x 2GB SS CF cards and my 80GB drive, no stress.

Cheers,


Rob Studdert
HURSTVILLE AUSTRALIA
Tel +61-2-9554-4110
UTC(GMT)  +10 Hours
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://members.ozemail.com.au/~distudio/publications/
Pentax user since 1986, PDMLer since 1998

Reply via email to