I would say the seller was confused by the box and did not intend to mislead. I would wait for the refund and then give the seller an *excellent* feedback. Making a mistake is easy but not all sellers are willing to make it right. Some of the worst sellers might even have accused you of "switching" the 52 for a 49 and THEN asking for a refund! Your seller sounds very honest and willing to do right.
Don > -----Original Message----- > From: Boris Liberman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2005 2:00 PM > To: [email protected] > Subject: EBay question (yet another) > > > Hi! > > I bought a 52 mm Pentax Ghostless UV filter off eBay for $20 including > shipping to Israel. What I received was a very clean 49 mm filter with > one little strange defect. It rattles inside its barrel. That is, it is > not fixed in it. > > Immediately after I paid, the seller left me a positive feedback. > > When I wrote to the seller that I have some problems with the item they > offered me full refund upon receiving the filter back. I am going to > accept that offer. > > The question is, what kind of feedback should I leave? Should I wait > until I receive full refund and only then leave the feedback? > > I am puzzled as it is the very first time in my practice that I received > an item rather different than it was originally described. > > What's rather amusing here is that the plastic box and paper box are > both from 52 mm filter... > > What do you say? > > Thanks. > > Boris >
