On Jan 4, 2006, at 6:50 PM, Steve Jolly wrote:

If that were the case, then moving the camera 24mm (or so) in any direction would result in a total change of picture, since according to your claim, everything that was originally visible on the sensor will have moved 24mm (or so) and will now be off it.

You can test this yourself: put any lens on any camera in your posession (I suggest a wide-angle). Look through the viewfinder. Keeping the camera pointing in the same direction, step sideways one step. Can you still see anything that was originally in the frame? If so, I'm afraid that your assumption is incorrect.


I just tested it in my studio this afternoon with a view camera. Focused on a wall and marked the location of a picture on the wall with a grease pencil on the GG. Moved the back laterally 10mm. Lo and behold, the picture was now exactly 10mm from the grease pencil outline. This is the same no matter what lens I put on the camera. Sorry, but you're wrong.

Bob

Reply via email to