Joseph,

although the picture is lovely and I like shooting roses too, I think you oversharpened this one. The petal edge on the right looks very unnatural to me.

And WRT your testing and comparison of D-FA and FA 50/2.8 macro, how did you judge focus?

Which body did you use? Did you focus by the screen, did you use focus confirmation in the finder, did you vary distances slightly? I have experienced deviations between the screen image and the final picture in the past, so I don't trustlens sharpness tests that don't take this into account, too. I do not want to say that you did sloppy testing. I just want to propose that the tested lenses might be even better, if you don#t trust the image on the focusing screen too much.

Pancho

Joseph Tainter schrieb:

Here's an early photo:

http://www.fotocommunity.com/pc/pc/cat/3537/display/5022625

Joe

Reply via email to