Patrick Genovese wrote on Sat, 08 Apr 2006 00:37:40:
Hi what's the general consensus regarding the quality/performance of Tamron's 17-35 or as it is officially known:SPAF17-35MM F/2.8-4 Di LD Asph (IF) http://www.tamron.com/lenses/prod/17_35mm.asp how would it compare to say a Pentax 20-35 f/4 or a pentax fa20 f/2.8 I know that's not comparing like with like but the thing is I was about to buy a 20 2.8 and got thinking whether the Tamron would be a wiser choice ?
I very much doubt if any third party zoom lens will equal the Pentax FA 20/2.8. The FA 20-35/4 is the best zoom in that range for the Pentax K-mount, and it is a very good performer. (I have both of these lenses). While I haven't got the Tamron I'd be quite surprised if it equals the FA20-35/4.
If you want the best optical/mechanical quality get the FA 20/2.8. If you want/need the added flexibility of a zoom, I'd recommend getting the FA20-35/4 if you can find it.
Regards, Jim
