Here are the submitted ratings: http://www.dariobonazza.com/provv/Street.xls
Have you seen that quite many pictures rank among the best for some judges and among the worst for others? Only two pictures are well above the rest and only two are well below. Any further comments? Thanks to: Wendy Beard Juan Buhler Cotty Godfrey DiGiorgi Graywolf Walter Hamler Maris V. Lidaka Sr. Brendan MacRae Bong Manayon Patrick Nelson Paul Stenquist Bob Sullivan Kenneth Waller Till the next time, Dario ----- Original Message ----- From: "Dario Bonazza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Pentax-Discuss Mail List" <[email protected]> Sent: Wednesday, May 02, 2007 12:16 AM Subject: Re: Speaking of judging photos... > OK, please stop sending me your ratings, as I already have enough of them. > Thanks a lot to you all! Now I'm going to put all of them on a xls file > and > then you can see how much different tastes there are around. Very > interesting! > > Thanks again to all folks helping me. > > Dario > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Dario Bonazza" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: "Pentax-Discuss Mail List" <[email protected]> > Sent: Tuesday, May 01, 2007 6:15 PM > Subject: Speaking of judging photos... > > >> ...I've asked five or seven members of this bunch, known for their >> involvement/interest in street photography, to help me choosing some B&W >> pictures out of 25 entries for a mini-exhibit at Pentax Day next May 20. >> >> Sadly, one week later I've only got one useful reply (thank-you, Juan). >> Sure >> I've done something wrong when asking that favour, as I don't think that >> simply rating 25 pictures is too heavy a task for anyone contributing >> daily >> to the list. There must have been something hurting in my request, but >> the >> lack of feedback hasn't helped me understanding my guilts. >> >> So, if that doesn't sound offensive, is there anyone willing to donate 5 >> minutes to help me asap? If so, please read directions below and then >> SEND >> ME YOUR RATINGS OFF-LIST! >> I'm afraid I won't consider onlist messages and voting, as they could >> turn >> into endless debate, flame and so on, and they can go ahead well past my >> deadline which had to be yesterday :-( >> When I'll think I've received enough ratings, I'm going to stop and do >> the >> sum. Then I'm going to publish a public matrix with all entries/judges >> (anonymous, if you think will fit better). That way, we'll see how >> variable >> those ratings can be. >> >> To make things as simple as possible, just fill the complete list of all >> 25 >> entries (below) with your score for each picture (1 = lowest, 10 = >> highest). >> Please try and use all the figures 1 to 10, OK? I mean that 1 should be >> the >> score for the worse picture(s) among these entries and 10 should be for >> the >> best picture(s) submitted here: >> http://www.dariobonazza.com/provv/Street.htm >> >> AL_1 = >> AL_2 = >> AL_3 = >> DA_1 = >> DA_2 = >> DA_3 = >> FA_1 = >> FA_2 = >> FA_3 = >> GE_1 = >> GE_2 = >> GE_3 = >> LE_1 = >> LE_2 = >> LE_3 = >> NI_1 = >> PH_1 = >> PH_2 = >> PH_3 = >> RE_1 = >> RE_2 = >> RE_3 = >> RO_1 = >> RO_2 = >> RO_3 = >> >> Thanks to anybody wishing to help. >> >> Dario >> >> >> -- >> PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List >> [email protected] >> http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net > -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List [email protected] http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
