I'll reply in all caps, point by point:

Nitin Garg wrote:

The 2 that I have experience with are xr-p and xr-m. Paul has used xr-p 
too and has given it favourable review here. 

ACTUALLY, I BROKE IT BEFORE I COULD USE IT. I STILL HAVEN'T FIRED A SHOT WITH A RICOH, 
SO MY OPINIONS ARE BASED ON SPECS, FEEL, REVIEWS, AND ONLINE COMMENTS I'VE SEEN.

He found it to have a less 
vibration compared to his Super A (wrong model?). 

UNQUESTIONABLY. AND LESS THAN THE XR-2S.

Our comparitive points 
about the 2 are: 

+ Bright viewfinder and 0.88x mag for xr-p (.80 for M).

THE BRIGHT FINDER WAS INTRODUCED ON THE XR-P (AND XR-10 AND 7, MAYBE) AND CONTINUED ON 
THE SUBSEQUENT PROGRAM MODELS: XR-X (XR-M IN USA), XR-3000 (A BUDGET MODEL), AND 
XRX-3P (THE FINAL HIGH-END MODEL). BUT THE XR-P WAS THE LAST TO USE THE 0.88X 
MAGNIFICATION; AFTER THAT, ALL USED, I THINK, 0.82X.
 
 Built in winder on xr-m (+ for me, - for paul. he prefers to attach winder 
if needed). 

YEP. YOU CAN THUS SEE THE WIND LEVER MOVING, FOR REASSURANCE. AND YOU CAN CHOOSE TO 
ADD A BATTERY-LADEN MOTOR, FOR HEFT, OR SIMPLY USE THE FEATHERWEIGHT GRIP, WITH ITS 
EXCELLENT AUXIILIARY SHUTTER RELEASE.

spot-metering in xr-m. not in xr-p. xr-m also has backlight compensation but 
thats usually better done yourself. 

THESE AND OTHER XR-M/XR-X FEATURES ARE ALSO FOUND ON THE XR-M'S REPLACEMENT, THE 
XRX-3P. ALSO, THESE TWO MODELS, UNLIKE THE XR-P, SHOW YOU THE SHUTTER SPEED ON A 
TOP-PANEL LCD. 

BUT AMONG RICOH PROGRAM BODIES, ONLY THE XR-P SHOWS YOU THE APERTURE IN A WINDOW IN 
THE VIEWFINDER.

The caveat ofcourse is getting program lenses (ricoh P lenses) is not 
easy. 

TRUE, BUT ONCE YOU HAVE IT, YOU HAVE IT. THE 50/2 IS A FINE LENS AND WIDELY AVAILABLE 
IN P, THOUGH IT WAS NEVER MULTICOATED. THE P 50/1.4 IS SCARCER THAN A PENTAX 50/1.2; 
I'VE NEVER SEEN ONE FOR SALE IN THREE MONTHS OF LOOKING.

One could try to make their pentax-a lenses into AP lenses :) or 
use 3rd party ones. 
YES, MANY THIRD-PARTY LENSES, ESPECIALLY VIVITAR'S, INCLUDE PROGRAM CONTACTS FOR 
PENTAX AND RICOH.

If the trend continues, soon I will not qualify to submit anything to PUG :) 

FEWER THAN HALF OF MY LENSES ARE NOW PENTAX, AND SOON THAT NUMBER WILL BE A THIRD. 
MIXING AND MATCHING IS ALL PART OF THE K-MOUNT ADVANTAGE.

CONCLUSION: ALL PROGRAM RICOHS OFFER TTL FLASH AND EASY VERTICAL SHOOTING. IF YOU LIKE 
THE CLASSIC CAMERA FEEL AND OPERATION OR MUST HAVE THE APERTURE WINDOW, GET THE XR-P. 
IF YOU PREFER MODERN AMENITIES, SKIP THE XR-M/XR-X AND GO FOR AN XR-X 3P. IT ADDS A 
1/3000 SECOND SHUTTER AND A BUILT-IN FLASH WITH 28MM COVERAGE AND EXCELLENT (EASY) TTL 
FLASH FILL.

[EMAIL PROTECTED]

--------------------------------------------------------------------
mail2web - Check your email from the web at
http://mail2web.com/ .
-
This message is from the Pentax-Discuss Mail List.  To unsubscribe,
go to http://www.pdml.net and follow the directions. Don't forget to
visit the Pentax Users' Gallery at http://pug.komkon.org .

Reply via email to