Vicinius wrote (5647-1) and (5647-2): "You don't see in the molecules of a gene any (5647-1) "image" or "concrete connection" with the phenotype it represents."
That is why a gene is a sign. ". . . But this does not lead to arbitrariness." (5647-2) One has to be careful in interpreting the word "arbitrariness" since it has multiple meanings depending on the context of the discourse. The way I use the term in my emails is in the sense of Saussure. That is, the one-to-one correspondence between a sign and its object that obtains (through habit) in a linguistic group is ARBITRARY in the sense that the same object can be in a one-to-one correspondce with a totally different sign in either the same linguistic group or different linguistic groups. With all the best. Sung > Sung wrote: > > S: "when we use these words, "symbol" (e.g., a flag), "index" (e.g., > weather vane direction), and "icon" (e.g., a cross) in everyday life, we > are most often, if not always, thinking of concrete material objects > referred to by these words and not the types of relations between them and > their objects." > > V: If you think of material objects, then what you have in your mind is > the > concept of material objects. This is a symbol. > > S "For example, when I (and I am sure many biologists as well) say that "a > gene is a symbol" or "a gene is acting as a symbol", I (we) mean that the > relation between a gene and its object (e.g., a phenotype) has a symbolic > character (e.g., arbitrariness, since more than one genes have been foudn > to encode a given phenotype)." > > V: Sure. You don't see in the molecules of a gene any "image" or "concrete > connection" with the phenotype it represents. But this does not lead to > arbitrariness. You won't find God or any other deity defining what each > gene must represent. Evolution and natural selection must do the trick by > habit formation and habit breaking. If it were arbitrary, all would be set > up at once. Being habitual, takes a very long time. > > S: "I also think that a gene has, in addition. > the indexical and iconic characters as well. In other words, a gene to me > has all three characteristics - iconic, indexical, and symbolic [1]. This > is why I feel more comfortable to refer to a gene as a sign, rather than > as a symbol, although I don't think the use of the latter term goes > against the basic tenets of the Peircean semiotics by any means as some > (or many ?) on this list seem to believe. > > V: A gene would have a iconic character if it would resemble its object. A > gene of blue eyes would be blue, for instance. An indexical character > would > mean that a gene of blue eyes would be found only in the eyes of people > with blue eyes. We don't see any of this going on. > A symbol is a sign, the sign that represents habitually its object. The > index is a sign, and so the icon. > I think your distinction is confusing. > Vinicius > > > 2014-03-26 13:36 GMT-04:00 Sungchul Ji <[email protected]>: > >> Vinicius wrote: >> >> "The symbol is non-material, purely informational." (5647-1) >> >> Isn't it true that all relations are non-material ? (5646-2) >> >> If so, then not only "symbol" (i.e., the symbolic relation between a >> sign >> and its object) but also "index" (i.e., the indexical relation between a >> sign and its object), and "icon" (i.e., the iconic relation between a >> sign >> and its object) must also be non-material. >> >> But, when we use these words, "symbol" (e.g., a flag), "index" (e.g., >> weather vane direction), and "icon" (e.g., a cross) in everyday life, we >> are most often, if not always, thinking of concrete material objects >> referred to by these words and not the types of relations between them >> and >> their objects. >> >> For example, when I (and I am sure many biologists as well) say that "a >> gene is a symbol" or "a gene is acting as a symbol", I (we) mean that >> the >> relation between a gene and its object (e.g., a phenotype) has a >> symbolic >> character (e.g., arbitrariness, since more than one genes have been >> foudn >> to encode a given phenotype). I also think that a gene has, in >> addition. >> the indexical and iconic characters as well. In other words, a gene to >> me >> has all three characteristics - iconic, indexical, and symbolic [1]. >> This >> is why I feel more comfortable to refer to a gene as a sign, rather than >> as a symbol, although I don't think the use of the latter term goes >> against the basic tenets of the Peircean semiotics by any means as some >> (or many ?) on this list seem to believe. >> >> With all the best. >> >> Sung >> ___________________________________________________ >> Sungchul Ji, Ph.D. >> Associate Professor of Pharmacology and Toxicology >> Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology >> Ernest Mario School of Pharmacy >> Rutgers University >> Piscataway, N.J. 08855 >> 732-445-4701 >> >> www.conformon.net >> >> >> Reference: >> [1] Ji, S. (2002). Microsemiotics of DNA. Semiotica 138 (1/4): >> 15-42. See Table 7 on p. 36. PDF available at conformon.net under >> Publications < Refereed Articles. >> >> >> > HP: Does the* index* have an *index vehicle*? Or is it a non-material >> > relation? Is the index a part of the DNA base sequence-to-protein >> > translation machinery? >> > >> > V: Index is the situadeness with all the concrete constraints involved >> in >> > a >> > particular moment, the chain of reations (as Koichiro is suggesting). >> The >> > symbol is non-material, purely informational. >> > >> > >> > 2014-03-25 7:47 GMT-04:00 Howard Pattee <[email protected]>: >> > >> >> At 08:11 AM 3/24/2014,Vinicius wrote: >> >> >> >> By itself, the symbol is useless. To function, a symbol needs indices >> >> attached to it. Indices are quantifiers. Frege and Peirce >> independently >> >> developed the theory of quantification in logic. When indices are >> >> attached >> >> to a symbol, it becomes a cognition, a "know-how" and only then it >> can >> >> do >> >> its job. >> >> >> >> >> >> HP: I have explained why isolated symbols are useless. I say symbols >> >> must >> >> be part of a "symbol system" I call a language. In the context of a >> >> cell, I >> >> do not understand the necessity of *indices*. In my view, a symbol >> >> requires only a *material symbol vehicle*, like a molecule (the >> molecule >> >> and an *interpreting mechanism *such as the cell's translation >> >> machinery). >> >> >> >> Does the* index* have an *index vehicle*? Or is it a non-material >> >> relation? Is the index a part of the DNA base sequence-to-protein >> >> translation machinery? >> >> >> >> Howard >> >> >> >> >> > >> > >> > -- >> > Vinicius Romanini, Ph.D. >> > Professor of Communication Studies >> > School of Communications and Arts >> > University of Sao Paulo, Brazil >> > www.minutesemeiotic.org >> > www.semeiosis.com.br >> > >> > Skype:vinicius_romanini >> > >> >> >> >> >> ----------------------------- >> PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON >> PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to >> [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L >> but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the >> BODY of the message. More at >> http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm. >> >> >> >>
----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .
