ECO ON PEIRCE **Part 5***28 Mar
2014 8:30 am OPEN TO REVISION & READ
ORIGINAL
-x-
[GCM: Ricoeur states, “[Yerushalmi’s] concluding reflections
are of great importance to us, once Jewish SINGULARITY is revealed to be
exemplary in regard to what the author himself calls “historiography and its
discontents” (Ricoeur p. 400, Yerushalmi p. 77), discontents to which the final
four lectures of ZAKHOR are devoted.” Yerushalmi “is not confined” to the 
“Wissenschaft
des Judentums” of the 1820s “but implies a radical critique of the theological
sense adhering to the Jewish memory AND amounts to adopting a historicist
IDEOLOGY that underscores the historicity of all things. The vertical relation
between the living eternity . . . cedes its place to a horizontal relation of 
causal
connections . . . More than others, pious Jews resent the “burden of history” 
(Ricoeur
n.82: Yerushalmi, p. 142, n. 14).¶ What is exemplary here is the correlation
between historiography and secularization, that is to say, for Jews, 
“assimilation
from without and collapse from within” (p. 85). For a providential conception
of history is substituted the notion of a secular Jewish history which would
unfold on the same plain of reality as any other history.¶ Thus . . . it is a
historiography separated from the collective memory and what remains in it of
nonhistoricized traditions (ECO: (p.60) 1.7: ”The ‘Ontologies’ [as] “metaphors
[that] require us to reorganize our categories” “under a certain description”
and create “a perspective”(p. 64) where “the problem of the need to forget” (p.
74, 1.9.2) leads to realizing “the dread of excess . . . [of] an enormous
quantity of lexical material” (p. 83, 1.9.4) which leads to “the primacy of
forgetting” in “the ‘ars excerpendi’ of compiling abstracts and summaries . . .
to retain only knowledge judged indispensable, and let marginal information
fall by the wayside”) RICOEUR: Inasmuch as in the Jewish culture “group 
memory…never
depended on historians in the first place” (Yerushalmi p. 94), the question of
the rebound effect of history on all memory is posed. Historiography,
Yerushalmi says for all of us, “represents, not an attempt at restoration of
memory, but a truly new kind of recollection” (p. 94, ECO “metaphor requires us
to reorganize our categories”). Yerushalmi asks whether it is a reasonable
project to want to save everything of the past. Does not the idea of forgetting
nothing reflect the madness of the person with total recall, the famous “Funes
the Memorious” of Jorge Luis Borges? Paradoxically, p. 401] the DELIRIUM OF
BEING EXHAUSTIVE proves to be contrary to the very project of doing history
(Yerushalmi: “The enterprise has become self-generating, the quest – 
Faustian…The
shadow of Funes the Memorious hovers over us all”, ZUKHOR, p. 102). Curiously,
Yerushalmi joins Nietzsche’s exclamation in the “Second Unfashionable
Observation”: “There is a degree of sleeplessness, of rumination, of ‘historical
sense’, that injures and finally destroys the living thing” (quoted in ZAKHOR,
145, n. 33). . . . Yerushalmi’s perplexity remains undiminished. One the one
hand, he listens to the therapeutic function of history. On the other, he hears
the antihistoricist words of Gerschom Scholem and Franz Rosenzweig. Caught
between two warring sides – “Today Jewry lives a bifurcated life” (p. 99) –
Yerushalmi takes on the “discontents” of the “professional Jewish historian”.
These discontents are everyone’s, the bastard children of Jewish memory and
secularized history.”
-----------------------------
PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L 
to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To 
UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the 
line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at 
http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .




Reply via email to