Dear Mark,
Thanks for your kind remark, and it is good to hear from you.
Peirce indeed talked about dialouge between two people and the role of a
sign in it. If my memory is correct, Peirce regarded a sign as a carrier
of information from A to B, so we may write:
Sign
Object ----------> Interpretant
which would then be similar to the fundamental triad.
I am just wodnering if the fundamental triad is a Peircean sign and a
Peircean sign is a fundamental triad. In other words, the fundamental
triad and the Peircean triad amy be two different names for the same
entity. Or, they may be different and related to each other
hierarchically as I suggested in the table attached. According to this
table, the fundamental triad is a morphism, while the Peircesn triad is a
functor. Let me know what you think.
With all the best.
Sung
---------------------------- Original Message ----------------------------
Subject: Re: [Fwd: Burgins Fundamental Triads as Peirceasn Signs.]
From: "Burgin, Mark" <[email protected]>
Date: Tue, July 15, 2014 8:59 pm
To: "Sungchul Ji" <[email protected]>
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Sung,
I was out of town and only now read your interesting e-mail. You found a
challenging connection between a Peircean sign and a fundamental triad.
You are a very creative person. What you suggest is a possible
interpretation. However, in general, a Peircean sign consists of three
fundamental triads. Besides, fundamental triad has more interpretations
than a Peircean sign . For instance, when an individual speaks or
e-mails to another individual, it is a fundamental triad but I don't
know how to interpret this system as a Peircean sign.
Sincerely,
Mark
On 7/5/2014 2:37 PM, Sungchul Ji wrote:
> Dear Mark,
>
> I just sent off this email to semioticians. Please let me know if you
> have any comments or corrections.
>
> With all the best.
>
---------------------------- Original Message ----------------------------
Subject: Re: [Fwd: Burgins Fundamental Triads as Peirceasn Signs.]
From: "Burgin, Mark" <[email protected]>
Date: Tue, July 15, 2014 8:59 pm
To: "Sungchul Ji" <[email protected]>
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Sung,
I was out of town and only now read your interesting e-mail. You found a
challenging connection between a Peircean sign and a fundamental triad.
You are a very creative person. What you suggest is a possible
interpretation. However, in general, a Peircean sign consists of three
fundamental triads. Besides, fundamental triad has more interpretations
than a Peircean sign . For instance, when an individual speaks or
e-mails to another individual, it is a fundamental triad but I don't
know how to interpret this system as a Peircean sign.
Sincerely,
Mark
On 7/5/2014 2:37 PM, Sungchul Ji wrote:
> Dear Mark,
>
> I just sent off this email to semioticians. Please let me know if you
> have any comments or corrections.
>
> With all the best.
>
> Sung
>
> ---------------------------- Original Message ----------------------------
> Subject: Burgins Fundamental Triads as Peirceasn Signs.
> From: "Sungchul Ji" <[email protected]>
> Date: Sat, July 5, 2014 5:33 pm
> To: [email protected]
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> (Undistorted figures are attached.)
>
> Stephen R on the Peirce list cited Peirce as saying:
>
> "The undertaking which this volume inaugurates is to (070514-1)
> make a philosophy like that of Aristotle, that is to say, to
> outline a theory so comprehensive that, for a long time to
> come, the entire work of human reason, in philosophy of
> every school and kind, in mathematics, in psychology,
> in physical science, in history, in sociology, and in
> whatever other department there may be, shall appear
> as the filling up of its details. The first step toward
> this is to find simple concepts applicable to every
> subject."
>
>
> At least one of the potential "simple concepts" that Peirce is referring
> to above may turn out to be his concept of "irreducible triadicity"
> embedded in the following quote that Jon recently posted and further
> explained in Figure 1 and (070514-4):
>
>
> Logic will here be defined as formal semiotic. (070514-2)
> A definition of a sign will be given which no more
> refers to human thought than does the definition of
> a line as the place which a particle occupies, part
> by part, during a lapse of time. Namely, a sign is
> something, A, which brings something, B, its interpretant
> sign determined or created by it, into the same sort
> of correspondence with something, C, its object, as
> that in which itself stands to C. It is from this
> definition, together with a definition of formal,
> that I deduce mathematically the principles of logic.
> I also make a historical review of all the definitions
> and conceptions of logic, and show, not merely that my
> definition is no novelty, but that my non-psychological
> conception of logic has virtually been quite generally
> held, though not generally recognized. (NEM 4, 2021).
>
>
> a b
> C --------> A --------> B
> | ^
> | |
> |_______________________________|
> c
>
> Figure 1. A diagrammatic representation of the principle of irreducible
> triadicity as applied to the definition of a sign. A = sign; B =
> interpretant; and C = object. a = the sign-object relation (which can be
> iconic, indexical or symbolic); b = the sign-interpretant relation (which
> can be rheme, dicisign or argument); c = the object-interpretant relation
> (which is lacking in Peircean semiotics but may be provided by
> microsemiotics [1] or biosemiotics (e.g., [2, 3, 4]).
>
>
>
> A is determined by C and determines B in such away (070514-3)
> that C is indirectly determined by B.
>
> The purpose of this email is to suggest the possible connection between
> the Peircean sign and Burgins fundamental triad shown in Figure 2 that is
> postulated by Burgin to underlie all mathematical constructions [5, 6].
>
> f
> X -------------- > I
>
> Figure 2. The fundamental triads (also called named sets) of Burgin
> [5, attached, 6]. X = set of objects called support; I = set of objects
> called names, and f = naming relation.
>
> The key to connecting Burigns triad and Peircean sign is to re-express
> the 2-node network in Figure 2 in the form of the 3-node network shown in
> Figure 3 which is expressed in words in (070514-4).
>
> a b
> X -------- > f --------> I
> | ^
> | |
> |_______________________________|
> c
> Figure 3. Burigns fundamental triad, Figure 2, re-expressed as an
> irreducible triad of Peirce, Figure 1. a = causality (?); b = convention
> (?); c = symbol grounding (?).
>
>
> X determines f which in turn determines I in such (070514-4)
> a way that I is constrained by or correlated with X.
>
>
> If the Burgin-Peirce connection depicted in Figure 3 turns out to be true,
> the following syllogism would result:
>
> Burgins fundamental triad can unify mathematics. [5, 6] (070514-5)
>
> Burigns fundamental triad is a Peircean sign. [Figure 3] (070514-6)
>
> Therefore Peircean sign (or semiotics) can unify (070514-7)
> mathematics. (Prediction}.
>
> With all the best.
>
> Sung
> __________________________________________________
> Sungchul Ji, Ph.D.
> Associate Professor of Pharmacology and Toxicology
> Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology
> Ernest Mario School of Pharmacy
> Rutgers University
> Piscataway, N.J. 08855
> 732-445-4701
>
> www.conformon.net
>
-----------------------------
PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L
to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To
UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the
line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at
http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .