Edwina, this difficulty you have with the very basic difference between science being conducted IN signs and one science (semiotics) being ABOUT signs explains a lot, to me, about why I have such difficulty trying to make sense of your semiotic theories.
ET: As for 'all of science is conducted in signs'...I think this is vague. Science is a human activity. Or, is this statement meant to refer to matter...i.e., all that is material is conducted in signs'. GF: Science is obviously an activity conducted by humans with the aim of learning something about nature. But just as the logical structures Frederik investigates in NP are NOT peculiar to human thinking, science in the full Peircean sense of the word is the activity that would be conducted by any community capable of learning from experience about nature, whether it's a human community or not, because it depends on argument in the semiotic sense. As Frederik puts it, we as a scientific species are 'adapted to reason', not inventors of it. It should be even more obvious that the statement does not "refer to matter". That idea could only make sense if you take "matter" as comprising everything that science studies, and I don't think even most physicists (let alone other scientists) would say that, even about physics! The vagueness you attribute to Frederik's statement is entirely a product of the nonsensical interpretation you propose for it. gary f. From: Edwina Taborsky [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 13-Sep-14 11:05 AM To: Peirce List; [email protected] Subject: [biosemiotics:6777] Re: [PEIRCE-L] Physics & Semiosis: the limited realm of physiosemiosis respecting physics John, I don't think that these opposing views - whether semiosic actions take place within the physico-chemical realm or only begin in the biological realm - can be definitively resolved. I, for one, like Stan, firmly believe that semiosis operates within the physico-chemical realm; that is, that even an atom emerges within a triadic relation - even if such atom has nil capacity for adaptation within that semiosis - as in the biological realm. As for 'all of science is conducted in signs'...I think this is vague. Science is a human activity. Or, is this statement meant to refer to matter...i.e., all that is material is conducted in signs'. I agree with Frederik that studying semiosic functions within the physico-chemical realm probably does little to provide new knowledge about that realm, but, I agree with Stan that it could examine the emergence of life from that realm. And I'm afraid that my intellectual dimness means that I can't see much difference between your pansemiosis and physiosemiosis...in that both acknowledge that semiosis operates within the physico-chemical realm. After all, physiosemiosis, in order to explore 'where and how', first has to acknowledge that semiosis actually exists in that realm. Edwina ----- Original Message ----- From: Deely, John N. <mailto:[email protected]> To: Frederik Stjernfelt <mailto:[email protected]> ; Peirce List <mailto:[email protected]> ; [email protected] Sent: Saturday, September 13, 2014 10:28 AM Subject: RE: [PEIRCE-L] Physics & Semiosis: the limited realm of physiosemiosis respecting physics Frederik says below: "nature has levels of organization, that the higher ones emerge from the lower ones, and the higher ones add new, organizational objects, relations, processes, combined of entities from the lower ones, but irreducible to them. You could say this implies that the possibility of semiosis lies in physics - but again that does not imply that those possibilities are realized in all physical processes." This is exactly the point of the difference between the term "physiosemiosis", which explores the question of exactly where and how "the possibility of semiosis lies in physics", and the term "pansemiosis", which implies that even in physics semiosis is everywhere to be found. And this is related to another of Frederik's well-made points: "all of science, no exception, is conducted IN signs. But this does not imply that all those sciences are ABOUT signs." Pansemiotics as a term bears connotation which miss this distinction entirely. This term has the fairly inevitable result, as Frederik puts the matter in another post, to "make the project of semiotics seem overblown and irrelevant to a scientific worldview."
----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .
