On October 31st, somebody at Bestweb failed to provide treats for the
ghosts and goblins, who took revenge by bringing down the email system.
 As a result, I lost three days of messages.
  
 Whether the phenomena are physical, ghostly, or just computer "bugs",
any ontology for science and engineering must be able to refer to them
before they can be analyzed and classified.
  
 As examples of physical "ghosts", consider phlogiston, neutrinos, and
dark matter.  The phlogiston theory proved to be false.  Neutrinos were
"ghostly" particles for many years before they were observed.  And dark
matter is still an unobserved hypothesis.
  
 An unexplained phenomenon:  A motion-activated camera detected ghostly
lights in the house where the composer Percy Grainger had lived and
worked:  http://minervaclassics.com/grainger/index.htm#haunted
  
 The spirits of the last three people who died in the house are suspects:
Percy's mother Rose, Percy himself, and his widow Ella.  Percy is the
prime suspect, but there may have been older ghosts.  Whether they exist
or not is irrelevant.  The existence of some kind of yet unknown
entities (physical or not) must be assumed.
  
 Following are two light streaks that occurred on 2 July 2016.  The date
suggests that some kids might have set off some fireworks in the
vicinity.  Perhaps a loud explosion might have caused vibrations that
activated the camera and turned on a light.  But the camera was
activated about 5 to 10 seconds before a streak of light appeared.
 The first streak went from the door to the hallway and flew across the
dining-room table, where Percy usually wrote his music:
  
 https://video.nest.com/clip/a414fbc0e1c7466a8a3701a50b98da41.mp4
  
 The second streak wavered near the ceiling above the place where the
first streak stopped and exited out the door where the first streak had
entered.  At the end of each video, there is an ad for the type of
camera that had recorded the incident.
  
 https://video.nest.com/clip/78208f34d9c746f18a90b149b0f6f342.mp4
  
 The blinds were drawn, and any light that may have come from the outside
could not (1) activate the motion detector or (2) appear to hover in the
middle of the room.
  
 The delay between the activation of the camera and the appearance of the
light streak was too long to be caused by the same explosion, and it
seemed to be too short to be caused by two different explosions.
  
 Another strange feature:  The light that illuminated the room was turned
on at the same instant that the camera began and it remained on until
the camera was turned off 20 seconds later.  That light was rather dim,
and the ghostly streaks of light were much brighter.  What seems strange
is that the light from the streaks did not make the room brighter.  The
room remained just as dim during the streaksas it was before and after
they passed through.
  
 Physical interpretation:  The so-called light streaks were not in the
room itself.  They were just caused by some electrical noise in the
circuitry that records the image from the camera.  But that hypothesis
is inconsistent with the fact that thunder (mechanical vibration) comes
after the lightning flash (electrical discharge).
  
 There were two other cameras in the house, neither of which was
activated:  one in the hallway monitored the front door, and one in the
kitchen monitored the back door.  Any motion that triggered the camera
in the dining room did not affect the other two.
  
 For a tour of the Grainger house and a view from the street, see
http://minervaclassics.com/grainger/grahouse.htm
  
 Conclusion:  This story shows the kinds of hypotheses that a scientist
must consider.  They can't all be true.  Perhaps none of them are true.
But a general-purpose ontology must accommodate an open-ended variety of
entities and relations among them.  Obvious hypotheses may be impossible
or impractical, and some fantasies may turn out to be true.  A premature
dismissal of fantasy can destroy creativity.
  
 John
  

  
  

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
► PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON 
PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . 
► To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message NOT to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] 
with UNSUBSCRIBE PEIRCE-L in the SUBJECT LINE of the message and nothing in the 
body.  More at https://list.iupui.edu/sympa/help/user-signoff.html .
► PEIRCE-L is owned by THE PEIRCE GROUP;  moderated by Gary Richmond;  and 
co-managed by him and Ben Udell.

Reply via email to