Differing WTO, UNCTAD perceptions
http://www.indiaserver.com/thehindu/2000/12/14/stories/0614000i.htm for full
article
THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in his annual
overview of the multilateral trading system, has raised concerns about the
increasing recourse of members to anti-dumping investigations and
countervailing duty measures. Though the use of AD/CV measures and
instruments figure regularly in the annual overview reports (since such
overviews came into being after the 1989 mid-term review), this year's
review, and the briefing to the media on the discussions in the General
Council last week, were focused on use of these instruments by developing
countries.
The WTO's Director of the Trade Policy Review Division, Mr. Clem Boonekamp,
told the press that the Council, sitting as the Trade Policy Review Body,
had focused attention on the resort to anti- dumping measures. What was
worrying was that the large users were developing countries, he said and
quoted approvingly the criticism of Hong Kong China that this was a ``bad
thing to do''. Mr. Boonekamp was questioned why the WTO secretariat did not
take this view in previous reports when the AD instruments were being used
by the U.S., Canada, EC and Australia among other industrialised countries,
whereas it was raising its voice and concerns that developing countries were
now using this instrument.
The AD is a `legitimate' trade instrument under the WTO/GATT, Mr. Boonekamp
acknowledged and had said it could be used under the rules. The first users
of the AD were industrialised countries and they were still large users. The
WTO was saying it was a legal instrument, but in applying it one should
``make sure it is being done in a legal way.'' The WTO report, in a section
under the title `Rising trend of anti-dumping and countervailing measures',
said the members had notified 360 initiations of AD investigations in 1999,
up 42 per cent over 1998.
In 1999, the EU and India each reported the highest number of initiations at
68, followed by the US with 45. An annex table said among others, Argentina
accounted for 24, Australia 23, Canada 18, Brazil and South Africa 16 each,
Indonesia 10, Turkey 8 and Korea 6. The report said the EU and its members
were the most affected by the initiation of AD actions (47), followed by
Korea 34, Japan 23. The report also said that the available data for the
first half of 2000 indicated a sharply downward trend. Between mid-1999 and
mid-2000, reports had been received of 235 investigations, compared to 313
during the earlier period.
Most members reported fewer initiations. The EU continued to be in the lead
with 49 initiations, followed by India and the US with 27 each, and
Argentina with 23. On average, half the initiations were terminated without
measures being applied, and the rest ended with anti-dumping duty or price
undertakings by the exporter. Despite a sunset clause in the agreement, the
accumulated stock of antidumping measures was rising steadily. At mid-2000,
there were an estimated final 1,119 measures in place of which the U.S.,
with 28 per cent, had the most; followed by the EU, 18 per cent, South
Africa, nine per cent, India, eight per cent and Canada, eight per cent.
However, an UNCTAD secretariat background note for an expert meeting this
week (where the U.S. and EC in effect appear to have blocked any
conclusions) put the issue in better perspective. The report said that the
AD/CV actions were legitimate measures permitted under the GATT/WTO and were
now the most frequently used trade remedies. Over the past decade, it says,
some 2,500 AD actions and almost 300 CV duty actions have been initiated and
notified to the GATT/WTO.
Developing countries, main target
The strengthening of the multilateral disciplines on safeguards, including
the prohibition and elimination of voluntary export restraints and
commitments to phase out the Multifibre Arrangement (MFA) quotas under the
Agreement on Textiles and Clothing (ATC), ``appears to have provoked an
increasing resort to anti-dumping measures'' with some countries and
sectors, such as steel and textiles, targeted more than others.
The UNCTAD report also notes that there has been increasing resort to
anti-dumping measures by non-traditional users, particularly developing
countries, many of which have introduced such legislation since entry into
force of the WTO. But developing countries continue to be the main targets
of anti- dumping measures, the report points out, and adds that this has the
effect of creating instability and uncertainty for their exports, resulting
in reduction in trade volumes and market shares for their goods.
The report brings out that prior to the Uruguay Round, the primary users
were developed countries - such as Australia, Canada, the EU and the U.S.
Over 1990-99, there were 2,483 AD cases initiated and notified. Of these 50
per cent were by the EU, Australia, Canada and the U.S. In addition, some
non- traditional users have resorted to such measures, accounting for 965
cases or 39 per cent of the total. Their increasing use, says UNCTAD, is due
to the pressure on their governments to adopt AD legislation to protect
domestic industries from imports following their significant reduction in
tariff and non-tariff measures during and after the UR.
Of the 1,254 cases initiated during 1990-94, developed countries accounted
for 867 cases or 69 per cent and developing countries, including transition
economies, for 387 cases or 31 per cent. During the first five years of the
WTO (1995-99), there were 1220 AD initiations of which 651 or 53 per cent
were by developed countries and 578 or 47 per cent by developing and
transition economies. The AD actions initiated by developing countries
increased by 16 per cent in this five year period. However, developing
countries are the main targets of the AD measures. During 1990-94, 469 or
37.4 per cent of the 1,254 cases were targeted at imports from developed
countries, compared with 785 cases or 62.6 per cent targeted at developing
and transition economies.
During the first five years of the WTO, 411 cases or 33.4 per cent of the
1,229 cases were targeted at developed country imports and 818 or 66.6 per
cent against imports from developing and transition economies. Also, the
major victims were China (159 cases), Korea 98, the US 79, Taiwan 60, Japan
58, Germany 50, India 48, Indonesia 47 and Russia 47. The UNCTAD report
brings out that the U.S. has also become one of the major targets of AD
actions by its trading partners, including many non-traditional users. As of
June 1998, U.S. products were subject to 163 foreign AD and CV measures
initiated by 20 trading partners including China and Taiwan.
Another trend is the increase in AD investigations by third countries
against the EU as a whole - even where the complaint contains allegations of
dumping by companies in one or two EU member states only. In the past,
trading partners used to impose AD measures on one or several EU members,
but not the EU as a whole. The report also brings out that there has been a
rise in antidumping actions initiated by developing countries against other
developing countries.