Julio Huato wrote: 
> I don't see the extravagant praise of Gaddafi that you found.
> 

Let's see.

* Castro presents the matter as a counterrevolutionary movement in the 
interests of European imperialism against a revolutionary soldier of the 
highest ideals.

 * He presents Gaddafi as part of a tradition of Libyan warrior greatness 
that stretches back to ancient Libyan soldiers who took part in Hannibal's 
campaign against the Roman Empire.

* Castro stresses that "As for me, I cannot imagine that the Libyan leader 
would abandon his country; escaping the responsibilities he is charged with".

* Meanwhile Castro says nothing whatsoever about what's happening to the 
Libyan working masses, and just has no idea whatsoever why anyone would be 
discontented with the regime. 

> Wrong or right, the fact is that the Cuban government, through its
> chancellor, has now repeated that it is up to the people of Libya to
> resolve this dispute internally, preferably in a peaceful manner,
> without the interference of foreign powers.  I think I can agree with
> that.

The Cuban government has thus described the slaughter of protesters as the 
people of Libya trying to solve their problems peacefully. This makes Castro 
into an apologist for this slaughter.

It's notable that Castro sees an uprising against an oppressive government, 
and identifies with the government. He says not a word about how the Libyan 
government is actually seeking to "resolve this dispute"; he doesn't see, in 
the masses rising, anything to inspire him; but he does worry about the bad 
press which the Libyan government is getting.

> But the issues on the ground appear murkier to me.  Compared to
> Tunisia, Egypt, or Bahrein, there's a very clear double standard in
> the reaction of NATO governments.  I am not confident enough in my own

Of course the EU and US imperialism are despicable. But so is the Libyan 
government, as revealed by its reaction to the uprising. 

> understanding of the local situation to dare a definitive political
> judgment.  But that does not matter.  What is at stake is my own peace

Castro was making a definitive political judgement.

\> of mind, with negligible effect on what actually happens there.  But,
> that applies to you and others here as well.
> 
-- Joseph Green
_______________________________________________
pen-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.csuchico.edu/mailman/listinfo/pen-l

Reply via email to