To take nothing away from my buddies at UMAS/Amherst, the R-R paper was hardly "the essential underpinning of the intellectual edifice of austerity economics." It pays us politically to hype this affair, but there is much more malignant substance to austerity economics than that diddly paper.
Of course like everyone else I'm loving the mileage we are getting from it. On Wed, Apr 24, 2013 at 2:17 PM, c b <[email protected]> wrote: > http://www.prwatch.org/node/12065 > > Pete Peterson Linked Economists Caught in Austerity Error > > by Mary Bottari — April 18, 2013 - 11:59am > Topics: Economy > Projects: Real Economy Project > Share this > A team of economists at the Political Economy Research Institute > (PERI) at UMass Amherst broke a huge story this week that was promptly > picked up by the New York Times, the Washington Post, the Financial > Times, and newspapers around the globe. The economists proved that the > essential underpinning "of the intellectual edifice of austerity > economics," as Paul Krugman put it, is based on sloppy methodology and > spreadsheet coding errors. > > Reinhart-Rogoff Study Debunked > > > Kenneth Rogoff and Carmen Reinhart > Three years ago, Harvard economists Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff > released a study that presented empirical evidence from 44 nations > over a 200 year time span to demonstrate that countries with a public > debt over 90 percent of GDP (the United States is at about 100 > percent, Japan at 200 percent) have average growth rates one percent > lower than other nations. > > Forty-four countries, 200 years, Harvard -- pretty convincing, huh? > > Except it was wrong. > > When the PERI team finally got a hold of the data used by Reinhart and > Rogoff, they uncovered gaping problems. They found that "coding > errors, selective exclusion of available data, and unconventional > weighting of summary statistics lead to serious errors that > inaccurately represent the relationship between public debt and GDP > growth." Adjusting for these errors, the Amherst team contends that > "the average real GDP growth rate for countries carrying a public > debt-to-GDP ratio of over 90 percent is actually 2.2 percent, not -0.1 > percent." > > It would all be a Massachusetts "Ivory Tower" kerfluffle if the > Reinhart-Rogoff study were not cited by practically everyone in > Washington, including Paul Ryan, Simpson-Bowles, and the entire "Fix > the Debt" crowd, to justify harmful cuts and a stalemate on stimulus > currently condemning millions to mass unemployment. > > And it should come as no surprise that the economists have ties to > Wall Street billionaire Pete Peterson. > > Study Used to Justify Harmful Cuts and High Unemployment > > It is hard to understate the importance of the study. It has been > cited around the globe by academics, politicians, and the mainstream > media. In the U.S., it is one of Paul Ryan's favorite justifications > for his draconian Path to Prosperity budget, for GOP rejection of > further stimulus, and the Fix the Debt crowd's frenzied calls for > urgent action. President Obama is now on the austerity bandwagon, > enacting numerous cuts and proposing new cuts to programs like Social > Security in order to achieve a "Grand Bargain" on deficits. As a > consequence, mass unemployment is a new normal. > > In Europe, "R&R's work and its derivatives have been used to justify > austerity policies that have pushed the unemployment rate over 10 > percent for the euro zone as a whole and above 20 percent in Greece > and Spain. In other words, this is a mistake that has had enormous > consequences" for real people, says economist Dean Baker in a piece > called "How Much Unemployment Did Reinhart and Rogoff's Arithmetic > Mistake Cause?" > > Time and time again, economists tried to replicate the Reinhart-Rogoff > results, but to no avail. Now, Thomas Herndon, Michael Ash, and Robert > Pollin show us why. One mistake, admitted by the authors and gaining > the most attention, is an Excel spreadsheet error. Check out the > screen shot of the year. > > As the authors put it: "A coding error in the RR working spreadsheet > entirely excludes five countries, Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, > and Denmark, from the analysis. [Reinhart-Rogoff] averaged cells in > lines 30 to 44 instead of lines 30 to 49... This spreadsheet error... > is responsible for a -0.3 percentage-point error in RR's published > average real GDP growth in the highest public debt/GDP category." > Belgium, in particular, has 26 years with debt-to-GDP above 90 > percent, with an average growth rate of 2.6 percent (though this is > only counted as one total point due to the weighting above). > > Mother Jones dubbed it "the Excel Error Heard Round the World." > > Pete Peterson's Fingerprints > > > It will come as no surprise that Reinhart and Rogoff have ties to Wall > Street billionaire Pete Peterson, a big fan of their work. Peterson > has been advocating cuts to Social Security and Medicare for decades > in order to prevent a debt crisis he warns will spike interest rates > and collapse the economy. (Peterson failed to warn of the actual > crisis building on Wall Street during his time at the Blackstone > Group.) > > When Washington Post writer Suzy Khimm pointed out to Peterson that > the U.S. built significant deficits during the financial crisis but > maintained very low interest rates, Peterson responded that America > still needed to be on high alert: "you know [Kenneth] Rogoff and > [Carmen] Reinhart -- I've talked to them, and they say [debt crises] > are sudden, they're sharp, they're very substantial. The risk is > simply too big. At some point, if we lurch from crisis to crisis, then > confidence will decline on our economy in general." > > As the Center for Media and Democracy detailed in the online report, > "The Peterson Pyramid," the Blackstone billionaire turned > philanthropist has spent half a billion dollars to promote this chorus > of calamity. Through the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, Peterson has > funded practically every think tank and non-profit that works on > deficit- and debt-related issues, including his latest astroturf > supergroup, "Fix the Debt," which has set a July 4, 2013 deadline for > securing an austerity budget. > > Reinhart, described glowingly by the New York Times as "the most > influential female economist in the world," was a Senior Fellow at the > Peterson Institute for International Economics founded, chaired, and > funded by Peterson. Reinhart is listed as participating in many > Peterson Institute events, such as their 2012 fiscal summit along with > Paul Ryan, Alan Simpson, and Tim Geithner, and numerous other Peterson > lectures and events available on YouTube. She is married to economist > and author Vincent Reinhart, who does similar work for the American > Enterprise Institute, also funded by the Peterson Foundation. > > Kenneth Rogoff is listed on the Advisory Board of the Peterson > Institute. The Peterson Institute bankrolled and published a 2011 > Rogoff-Reinhart book-length collaboration, "A Decade of Debt," where > the authors apparently used the same flawed data to reach many of the > same conclusions and warn ominously of a "debt burden" stretching into > 2017 that "will weigh heavily on the public policy agenda of numerous > advanced economies and global financial markets for some time to > come." (Note that not everyone associated with the Institute touts the > Peterson party line.) > > Bankrupt Analysis > > > The authors have issued two rebuttals to the Amherst study. In their > latest, they object that anyone would think they were "misconstruing > analysis to support austerity" or a political agenda. Perhaps it had > to do with pieces like this one entitled "Too Much Debt and the > Economy Can't Grow" that warns against further stimulus at a time when > mass unemployment is wreaking devastation on the lives and livelihoods > of workers young and old. > > Economists like Herndon, Ash, Pollin, Baker, and Krugman have never > bought the argument that economies can cut their way out of a crisis, > and now data from the Reinhart-Rogoff study, from numerous European > countries, from the IMF, and even from CMD's home state of Wisconsin > (now ranked an astonishing 44th in job creation), support their > contentions. > > If only they had half a billion to spread the word. > _______________________________________________ > pen-l mailing list > [email protected] > https://lists.csuchico.edu/mailman/listinfo/pen-l >
_______________________________________________ pen-l mailing list [email protected] https://lists.csuchico.edu/mailman/listinfo/pen-l
