CB:> Yea, I'm trying to think of a Marxist on these lists or elsewhere who
thinks capitalists are one quarter or 40 quarters from collapsing themselves
into socialists.  Can somebody _name_ a Marxist who thinks that capitalists
will collapse "on their own" without a massive ( tens of millions ),
class-conscious and organized group of workers to overthrow them ? All
Marxists I've ever heard speak on the issue hold that a big economic crisis
in capitalism only provides an opportunity ( and danger of fascism) for a
communist movement to take state power, not that the capitalists on their
own, because of a crisis , would turn to socialism.

>I think the "Marxist" who think capitalists will automatically turn
themselves into socialists is one of those "Marxists" who Marx was not one
of....<

this is right. the "Marxists" who see an automatic fall 
of capitalism are more like the utopian Edward Bellamy 
who saw the centralization of capital producing a big 
monopoly which people would see as totally irrational, 
so that they'd turn it into a undemocratic-but-benevolent
planned socialism. and there would be no resistance from
the monopoly.
JD

Reply via email to