Sabri asks:
Any comments from our friends in South America?
Sabri
UPDATE 7-Ex-president leads nationalist in Peru runoff vote
By Robin Emmott

LIMA, Peru, June 4 (Reuters) - Former President Alan Garcia led a fiery
ex-army nationalist in Peru's runoff election on Sunday, staging a political
comeback after his 1980s government ended in economic ruin, rebel violence
and accusations of rights abuses, unofficial counts showed.

If officially confirmed, the result would be a blow for Venezuela's
President Hugh Chavez, who sparked a diplomatic spat with Peru after trying
to take advantage of a populist anti-U.S. tide in Latin America by
supporting Ollanta Humala, a former army commander.

[I am probably not who you wanted.  No one else has replied, so if its ok...]

The final vote predictably followed the path established by the first
round.  Indeed, voters held closely to class, racial and regional interests
(although the candidates had no intention of representing those interests).

1)      Humala retained his base from the 1st round: the indigenous areas
from the south (i.e. 70% in Cuzco, 80% in Ayacucho, birthplace of Sendero
Luminoso).  The people with roots in this background (35% of the voters in
the first round) have actively turned their backs on neo-liberalism for 25
years...but without the leadership or organization to give clear and
effective expression.  Humala's "limitations"  prevented him from  reach
out beyond his base in the second round (only Fujimori voters, a "lost"
group, moved to Humala in the second round).  To win an election, any
candidate with this base must also add voters from the left, organized
workers, people from "mixed" racial backgrounds or indigenous but not
Quechua speakers.  Although he tried to portray himself as in the
Chavez/Morales mold, Humala, with his past, could not be that candidate.

2)      Garcia also retained his base: for half a century APRA has had near
cult-like status among the informal working class of the North (and the
migrants to Lima).  This 25% of the country also believes they voted
against neo-liberalism in the first round of the elections.

However, in the 2nd round Garcia was also able to attract over half of
those who voted for the right or center parties in the first round - he
practically campaigned on an offer to accelerate the long trend of APRA
"selling out" its base.  The other part of these right and center voters
still could not stomach APRA the "50 year demon" along with Garcia's
catastrophic failures - they cast null ballots or stayed home (Peru has
firm traditions of public participation in politics and voting is
compulsory).  This rightwing and center support swung the difference to
Garcia.

[Despite the international press reports, "Chavez" was not, in himself, an
important issue, IMO.  Garcia did indeed succeed in baiting Chavez (for
weeks before Chavez took the bait) hoping for the chance to show right wing
voters he too hated vulgar popularists (think Clinton-Sister Soulja or
Sarkozy-racaille).  But this was a small part of a far larger effort by
Garcia to play to the right and center voters.]

3)      In the long run where will this lead?  60% of Peru voted angrily
against neo-liberalism and got...nothing.  Electoral politics are only
frustrating them with most "big" decisions being taken anyway in Washington
or locked in by trade regimes and financial arrangements.

One can't help but thinking that at some point things will explode
again.  But (as the Sendero Luminoso fiasco shows) will it be in a
constructive and productive manner?

4)      In the short run a narrow gamut of superficial political choices
will depend on what promises to be shabby back room dealing for a
Parliamentary majority.

APRA (Garcia's party) won only 30% of the seats in Parliament.  Humala's
"party" won 38% BUT that party was actually "rented" to him (it is a small
neo-liberal party that ran Perez de Cuellar for President in '95).  No one
knows what percentage of its Parliamentarians are actually Humalista's vs
old guard, and in any case many will make deals - that was the point of the
rental.  The neo-liberals and the centrists together have under 20% of the
seats.  The Fujimoristas have 10% (!).

In short, there will be a fluid scramble for power in the formation of a
government.  Even after that alliances may continuously shift (for example
over whether to ratify the "free" trade agreement with the U.S.).

The other short run uncertainty will be Garcia's own impulses.  As
President in the '80s he was erratic under pressure, to put it mildly.

Paul

Reply via email to