*       From: Jim Devine Chávez is no Castro

Neither the excesses nor the achievements of the Venezuelan leader are
in the same béisbol-park as his cigar-puffing neighbour.

Ben Whitford

^^^^^^
CB: I think this is harmless nonsense, not likely to do any harm to the
American revolutionary movement, led by Cuba and Venezuela.

Who is the author trying to persuade that Chavez is not like Castro ? People
who are already fans of Castro or Chavez aren't likely to pay much attention
to the article. So, what impact is he trying to have on people first hearing
of Chavez ? I assume somehow he is trying to make them dislike Chavez.
Well, of the people only learning about Chavez now in this author's
audience, U.S.ians, most of them are probably already heavily propagandized
to be anti-Castro. So , the title , distancing Chavez from Castro would ring
favorably for Chavez for the anti-Castro lights, the generalized, vaguely
anti-Castro average American. "Chavez is not like Castro. Oh, Chavez good".
Are they really likely to get deep into the article's analysis to receive
the anti-Chavez themes ? I doubt most average Americans would read it that
far or think about it that much . They've been trained to think very
shallowly about the issues in this article. And the shallow message is
mildly pro-Chavez ; and even untrue, since Chavez _is_ like Castro in
important ways; both Chavez and Castro are saying it. It would seem that
Castro and Chavez _are_ in the same park, as that expression goes. How odd
to take the tack of denying that they are alike like that. 

 I don't know what this guy is doing in this article. Trying out some new
tricks, since the old ones' are working that good ? Maybe this reporter is a
covert leftist or something.

Reply via email to