Reading this discussion, I'm getting the feeling that filename literals are increasingly getting magical, something that I don't think is a good development. The only sane way to deal with filenames is treating them as opaque binary strings, making any more assumptions is bound to get you into trouble. I don't want to deal with Windows' strange restrictions on characters when I'm working on Linux. I don't want to deal with any other platform's particularities either. Portability should be positive, not negative IMNSHO.
As for comparing paths: reimplementing logic that belongs to the filesystem sounds like really Bad Idea™ to me. Two paths can't be reliably compared without choosing to make some explicit assumptions, and I don't think Perl should make such choices for the programmer. Leon Timmermans
