Bjoern, please don't take my reassertion of the problem I wanted to talk about 
as an indication that I consider the problem you want to talk about 
unimportant.   I agree that online ads present an attack surface, and that we 
should think about that.   I'm quite aware that my computer is running programs 
at the behest of ad networks (well, actually it's not, because I don't allow 
Flash in my web browser, but I certainly agree with you in principle).

The point of what I said previously was to talk about another attack surface 
with different characteristics.   The problem you are describing is one that's 
already on the radar of most of us tin-foil-hat wearers.   I just wanted to get 
an additional problem which is similar but really meaningfully different on the 
radar as well.

What's interesting about the http-with-identifying-info attack is that it can 
be easily prevented by not including identifying info or by using https.   
Unfortunately the targeted-ad attack can't be addressed in this way, but that 
doesn't mean that the http-with-identifying-info attack isn't worth addressing.

_______________________________________________
perpass mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/perpass

Reply via email to