On Fri, Feb 12, 2016 at 9:20 AM, Paul T. Bauman <[email protected]> wrote:
> Hi Barry, > > On Thu, Feb 11, 2016 at 2:45 PM, Barry Smith <[email protected]> wrote: > >> >> > On Feb 11, 2016, at 1:36 PM, Boris Boutkov <[email protected]> >> wrote: >> > >> > Hello All, >> > >> > I'm currently working on hooking into the PETSc multi-grid >> infrastructure by creating my own DMShell and providing my own >> interpolation and injection operators. The issue I am currently facing is >> that while PCSetUp_MG is running, PETSc begins by attempting to create an >> interpolation (through DMCreateInterpolation) for the finest grid that I am >> passing it. >> > >> > What would be a good way to try and let the PCSetUp_MG procedure know >> the first mesh it is receiving is the finest one, so there should be no >> interpolation provided to it? >> >> Boris, >> >> I do not understand the question, perhaps it is a matter of language. > > Say you have two levels total: call them coarse and fine. the PCSetUp_MG >> will try to create a single interpolation "for/to the fine grid" FROM the >> coarse grid. This is necessary to do the geometric multigrid. You would >> then through your DMSHELL provide the function that creates the >> interpolation matrix. The PCSetUp_MG will not attempt to create an >> interpolation "for the coarse mesh" since there is no mesh coarser than the >> coarse mesh. So >> PCSetUp_MG() should be trying to create only the needed interpolations, >> so you should not need to tell them not to try to create certain ones. > > > The information I think we're missing is, more or less, the order of > operations during the MG setup and how PETSc is expecting us to behave with > our DMShell implementation. I'll stick with your coarse and fine grid. On > our side, we can construct the coarse and the fine grids, supplying the DMs > and accompanying PetscSections, at simulation setup time since we know what > our grid hierarchy is (we're focusing on hierarchical meshes to start > with). Then, for DMRefine and DMCoarsen, we can just return the correct DM > that we've built. (Maybe this the wrong way to do it?) We also have > implementations of DMCreateInterpolation and DMCreateInjection for moving > between each of the levels. > > Our main confusion is, once we've set up of all that, which of the DMs > we've constructed do we go ahead and give to SNES? The fine or the coarse? > Is it expected that we should be checking the DM supplied to, e.g., > DMCreateInterpolation for which of the operators PETSc is wanting? We were > guessing that we should supply the fine DM to SNES (and then not expecting > DMCreateInterpolation to be called yet). > Ah, good question. I think it should be the fine grid, and this is the default for FAS. Some stuff used to take a coarse grid because DMDA was easier to refine, but that should all be fixed now. Also, it looks like Lawrence responded. Matt > Clearly, there's some setup steps we're missing or we're just going about > this all the wrong way. Is there an existing example of setting up a > problem using a DMShell? I poked a little but couldn't find one. > > Thanks much. > > Best, > > Paul > -- What most experimenters take for granted before they begin their experiments is infinitely more interesting than any results to which their experiments lead. -- Norbert Wiener
