On 2017/04/05 10:30, A Hofer wrote: > This thread sums up my problem exactly, but they don't seem to think > there is a solution which surprises me. > > https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/58832/ > > Basically I'm trying to get some PC's and consoles to have NAT type 1 and > so far I can only get one of them working properly at any time without > resorting to upnp. > > Could use some help, thanks.
PF only has what is often referred to as "port-restricted cone nat", if you want to allow incoming traffic to reach an internal machine that's not in response to an outgoing connection then you're going to need rdr-to or some other mechanism to poke holes in the firewall.
