----- Forwarded message from David Reed <[email protected]> -----

Date: Thu, 19 Sep 2013 18:34:04 -0400
From: David Reed <[email protected]>
Subject: [ITAC] On the subject of ITU-T and Internet Governance
Reply-To: [email protected]
To: [email protected]
Importance: Normal


Coming back to my general position: why does the Internet need "governance"?
 
The English language (a remarkable set of protocols that enable general purpose 
commercial and non-commercial communications, which evolves over time, supports 
radical innovation, etc.) does not need "governance" and has been very 
successful in markedly changing the world.   Whereas "governed protocols" like 
French, generally have not.
 
I'm not suggesting a cultural bigotry here - one could make the same argument 
for Chinese and Arabic.
 
What has happened in the last 40 years with the Internet is that communications 
has become interoperable in the digital world, just as written and spoken 
English became a shared tongue, without "governance".
 
It would be laughable if there were a UN-sponsored organization defining 
English and "governing" all discourse means associated with it.  Can you 
imagine a standard for mapping English negotiation of a commercial contract, 
depending on the specific type of paper and print-head?
 
The whole point of the Internet (both in formation and today) is *exactly* the 
same as the point of English.  If you don't see that, I think you are wearing 
blinders - to a political scientist or lawyer, every problem requires 
interposition of the maximum number of bureaucrats to prevent success.  (that's 
exaggeration, of course, but before dismissing it out of hand, try thinking 
clearly about it).
 
We did need to standardize really artificial and limited technical 
communication protocols when we did not have such a vibrant and interconnected 
world.  Morse Code was far from standard at the beginning, because the world 
was disconnected.
 
But today the world is completely connected (by the Internet).  Just as we no 
longer need "governance" of Morse Code - and for *exactly* the same reasons! - 
we don't need "governance" of the Internet.   The benefits of interoperability 
cause the system to evolve coherently, not incoherently.
 
However, if the goal is to work very hard to "break the Internet", balkanizing 
it, and somehow preventing communications from working very well, then we need 
"governance".
 
3GPP (whatever you think of it, and I don't think it works very well at all, 
technically, as the disaster that is LTE shows in its weaknesses and deployment 
flaws), is not a "governance" organization.  Please keep the political 
scientists out of it, they are not needed.
 
If the US State Dept. wants to work on international communications as an 
issue, it would be far more productive to step back and stop listening to the 
big operators of networks - they are very good at twisting the conversation 
into modes of "capture" that give them commercial advantage, while interfering 
with the goals of communicators (the endpoints).
 
So defunding ITU-T would be a very good idea.  If countries want to try to cut 
themselves off from the Internet, and develop "proprietary" private networks - 
they will fail.  They will destroy their economies.  Let them fail.  Let their 
commercial interests and their civil society interests discover how badly their 
governments are damaging them.
 
Meanwhile, it would be great if the US State Dept. would stand up against the 
outrageous behavior revealed in the latest revelations about universal capture 
and recording of all communications traffic for later analysis and use.   This 
is embarrassing the country.  It's not Snowden who is embarrassing the US.   It 
is the US Executive Branch and its judicial branch's *collusion* with that 
embarrassment that is destroying the US's standing in the communications world.
 
I cannot imagine how a US Diplomat can justify what the US has been doing, at 
the scale it has been doing it and keep a straight face.


On Thursday, September 19, 2013 5:23pm, "Tony Rutkowski" 
<[email protected]> said:



> In doing any opining here, it would be useful
> for ITU-T supporters to:
> 
> 1) provide the statistics that in terms
> of document contributions, participation,
> and held positions, show that the ITU-T hasn't
> basically tanked over the past ten, five, one
> year; and
> 
> 2) why an intergovernmental technical
> body is necessary for the standards work
> being pursued; and
> 
> 3) that the work isn't already being pursued
> on a far larger scale in one of the many
> global bodies now available.
>
----- End forwarded message -----

--Lauren--
Lauren Weinstein ([email protected]): http://www.vortex.com/lauren 
Co-Founder: People For Internet Responsibility: http://www.pfir.org/pfir-info
Founder:
 - Network Neutrality Squad: http://www.nnsquad.org 
 - PRIVACY Forum: http://www.vortex.com/privacy-info
Member: ACM Committee on Computers and Public Policy
Lauren's Blog: http://lauren.vortex.com
Google+: http://google.com/+LaurenWeinstein 
Twitter: http://twitter.com/laurenweinstein
Tel: +1 (818) 225-2800 / Skype: vortex.com
_______________________________________________
pfir mailing list
http://lists.pfir.org/mailman/listinfo/pfir

Reply via email to