Android In-App Payments Abuse Nightmares: Why Google Is Complicit

https://lauren.vortex.com/2018/05/24/android-in-app-payments-abuse-nightmares-why-google-is-complicit


Should an Android app aimed at children include a $133 in-app purchase
for worthless virtual merchandise? If you're the kind of crook who
runs fake real estate "universities" and stiffs your workers via
multiple bankruptcies, you'd probably see nothing wrong with this. But
most ethical people might wonder why Google would permit such an
abomination. Is the fact that they take a substantial cut of each such
transaction clouding their usually excellent ethical sensibilities in
this case? Or is Google somehow just unaware, underestimating, or
de-emphasizing the scope of these problems?

Complaints regarding in-app Android purchases arrive at my inbox with
notable regularity. But one that arrived recently really grabbed my
attention. Rather than attempt to summarize it, I'm including extended
portions of it below (anonymized and with the permission of the
authors).

Beyond the details of how parental locks and Google Play Store payment
systems are designed and the ways in which they could be greatly
improved, a much more fundamental problem is at the core of these
issues.

I have long considered in-app purchase models to be open for enormous
abuse. Where they are used to "unlock" actual capabilities in
non-gaming applications, they can play a useful role. But their use
for the purchase of worthless "virtual" goods or points in games,
especially when total purchases over the lifetimes of the games can
add up to more than a few dollars, are difficult to justify. They are
impossible to justify in games that are targeted at children.

Though apparently entirely legal, it is unconscionable that Google
permits these sorts of apps to exploit children and their parents, and
then refuses to offer full refunds to parents who have been victimized
as a result, particularly when those parents have attempted to
diligently use the payment control mechanisms that are currently
available.

Not Googley at all. Shame on you, Google.

-Lauren-

 - - - - - -

[Permission for posting of these materials in anonymized form has been
received from all associated parties. - Lauren]

Hi Lauren,

Thanks so much for considering this. [ ] is:  [ ]@gmail.com - she's
fine with you sharing that with Google.

If it can happen to someone of her education what hope do the rest of
us have... let alone a 4-year old who can't read. She says also it's
fine to share her story, fully anonymised ... It's pretty horrible and
I suspect also pretty widespread too....

On 05/23 09:16, [ ] wrote:

hi Lauren,

I'm sure you've heard lots of these kinda stories, so your indulgence
is requested. Friend of mine - who holds a doctorate in business, no
less - got a bill for around GBP 650 [currently about $870 - Lauren]
after her 4-year old daughter was able to buy in-game despite parental
locks. Or, that's what my friend thought: Google said that updating
the unit could wipe out those locks. And no refund is thus
forthcoming. She has contacted the app developers too but obviously
they're happy enough with her money so nothing doing there. [Response
from developer refuses to issue any refund - Lauren]

Two things:

(1) Why does an update clear locks? This is surely bad practice?

(2) How the hell can anyone justify a GBP 100 in-app purchase in a
game directed at toddlers? This one can't read yet and as we know,
kids are experts on using touchscreen tech before any language skills
develop.

P.S. any advice welcome - thanks loads

 - - -

My 4 year old loves watching [ ]. On [ ] (Freeview) one of her
favourite cartoons is [ ]. She loves this so much that she asked if
she could download [ ] on my mobile phone to play. I obliged and made
the usual checks; no ads, and parental locks engaged. She then asked
to download another similar game; [ ]. She absolutely loves this game,
and for a 4 year old, she's got pretty good at it... certainly better
than me and her big sis.

Again, I made sure parental lock and no ads were ticked within the
app.... Last Friday I received a telephone call from the Fraud dept.
at [ ] Credit Card, they suspected fraudulent activity on my card - in
fact one transaction of GBP 99.99 and another of GBP 1.99 had gone on
my card that morning.. and I hadn't even left my house. I was
obviously shocked and concerned - they said the payee was Google Play.

They asked if I had an android phone and whether I let me kids play on
the phone. I said yes, but all games are 'locked down' so to speak.
She asked me to go into my phone to check... to my sheer horror, I saw
a long list of 'in-app' purchases made by my 4 year old within the
space (mostly) of three weeks. Now I usually check my credit card
spends at the end of every month, and I hadn't got around to checking
for this month. I quickly toted up the separate transactions and
figured that she had burned GBP 498.88 buying '[ ].. GBP 99.99 and '[
] 1.99/ 29.99' within the [ ] game.

I was totally in shock and rightly upset. Of course this wasn't her
fault - she can't read.. but how can an app associated with a
children's cartoon think its OK to embed in app purchases within their
game ... Google have informed me that updating my android can wipe out
all the parental locks etc, and I have to check/ re-engage all locks
etc after EVERY software upgrade. I contacted Google, and they have
disappointingly refunded only GBP 70.00 - stating that its outside
their T&Cs and that I need to request a refund from [ ]; the App
developers.

I've emailed [ ], they haven't bothered to respond (I've waited 72
hours and counting now) [Eventual response refused to refund -
Lauren]. I've also contacted [ ] Credit Card, and they've said that
they won't help me... Surely this is 'Soft Fraud' and this is
unethical and wrong... so parents please beware. This has and still is
really upsetting for both me and my daughter. Please share and just be
hyper careful on your phones. Here is most of her spending spree!!
[Details of purchases for "virtual products" from the described app,
ranging from GBP 1.99 to GBP 99.99 - Lauren]

 - - - - - -

--Lauren--
Lauren Weinstein ([email protected]): https://www.vortex.com/lauren 
Lauren's Blog: https://lauren.vortex.com
Google Issues Mailing List: https://vortex.com/google-issues
Founder: Network Neutrality Squad: https://www.nnsquad.org 
         PRIVACY Forum: https://www.vortex.com/privacy-info
Co-Founder: People For Internet Responsibility: https://www.pfir.org/pfir-info
Member: ACM Committee on Computers and Public Policy
Google+: https://google.com/+LaurenWeinstein
Twitter: https://twitter.com/laurenweinstein
Tel: +1 (818) 225-2800
_______________________________________________
pfir mailing list
https://lists.pfir.org/mailman/listinfo/pfir

Reply via email to