As September has ended, I have closed commitfest 2023-09. The status before I started moving patches over was

Status summary: Needs review: 189. Waiting on Author: 30. Ready for Committer: 28. Committed: 68. Moved to next CF: 1. Returned with Feedback: 16. Rejected: 1. Withdrawn: 5. Total: 338.

The final status is now

Status summary: Committed: 68. Moved to next CF: 248. Withdrawn: 5. Rejected: 1. Returned with Feedback: 16. Total: 338.

The "Committed" number is lower than in the preceding commitfests, but it is actually higher than in the September commitfests of preceding years.

I did some more adjustments of status and removal of stale reviewer entries. But overall, everything looked pretty accurate and up to date.

In the November commitfest right now, there are more than 50 patches that are 2 or 3 CFs old (meaning they arrived after PG16 feature freeze) and that have no reviewers. Plus at least 30 patches without reviewers that are completely new in the November CF. Also, it looks like a lot of these are in the Performance category, which is typically harder to review and get agreement on. So, while we do have some really old patches that, well, are hard to get sorted out, there is a lot of new work coming in that really just needs plain reviewer attention.


Reply via email to