On 2019-Sep-03, Stephen Frost wrote: > Greetings, > > * David Fetter (da...@fetter.org) wrote: > > I'd like to $Subject, on by default, with a switch to turn it off for > > those really at the outer edges of performance. Some reasons include: > > Sure, half of contrib should really be in core (amcheck, file_fdw, > postgres_fdw, maybe dblink, pageinspect, pg_buffercache, > pg_freespacemap, pgstattuple, pg_visibility, sslinfo, maybe pgtrgm..) > but we simply haven't got great facilities for either migrating those > things into core (particularly during an upgrade..)
I think there is a false dichotomy here. Migrating an extension out of contrib doesn't have to equate making it no longer an extension. We could, instead, keep it being an extension, but move it out of contrib and into (say) src/extensions/ so that it becomes installed and available by default, but still an extension. Users won't have to install a separate contrib package, but they would still have to run CREATE EXTENSION. We don't incur the upgrade pain if we do that, for one thing. Also, we don't force everybody to have it; and we don't have to invent this hypothetical switch to turn it off. -- Álvaro Herrera https://www.2ndQuadrant.com/ PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Remote DBA, Training & Services
