Hello David,
Thank you for your reply.
> Can you share if these times were to run EXPLAIN ANALYZE or if they
> were just the queries being executed normally?
These times were to run EXPLAIN ANALYZE. I executed each query twice,
and the **average** execution time was shown in the table of the last
e-mail. Therefore, the result of the table is not simply equal to that
of the attached file. I'm sorry for the insufficient explanation.
> It would be really great if you could show the EXPLAIN (ANALYZE,
> TIMING OFF) for query 62. There's a chance that the slowdown comes
> from the additional EXPLAIN ANALYZE timing overhead with the Result
> Cache version.
I ran query 62 by "EXPLAIN (ANALYZE, TIMING OFF)" and normally. I
attached these execution results to this e-mail. At this time, I
executed each query only once (not twice). The results are as follows.
Method | Execution time with result cache (s) | Execution time
without result cache (s) | Speedup ratio
EXPLAIN (ANALYZE, TIMING ON) 67.161 59.615 -12.66%
EXPLAIN (ANALYZE, TIMING OFF) 66.142 60.660 -9.04%
Normal 66.611 60.955 -9.28%
Although there is variation in the execution time, the speedup ratio
is around -10%. So, the result cache has a 10% regression in query 62.
The overhead of EXPLAIN ANALYZE and TIMING ON do not seem to be high.
Best regards,
Yuya Watari
On Tue, Apr 13, 2021 at 7:13 PM David Rowley <dgrowle...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> On Tue, 13 Apr 2021 at 21:29, Yuya Watari <watari.y...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > I used the TPC-DS scale factor 100 in the evaluation. I executed all
> > of the 99 queries in the TPC-DS, and the result cache worked in the 21
> > queries of them. However, some queries took too much time, so I
> > skipped their execution. I set work_mem to 256MB, and
> > max_parallel_workers_per_gather to 0.
>
> Many thanks for testing this.
>
> > As you can see from these results, many queries have a negative
> > speedup ratio, which means that there are negative impacts on the
> > query performance. In query 62, the execution time increased by
> > 11.36%. I guess these regressions are due to the misestimation of the
> > cost in the planner. I attached the execution plan of query 62.
>
> Can you share if these times were to run EXPLAIN ANALYZE or if they
> were just the queries being executed normally?
>
> The times in the two files you attached do look very similar to the
> times in your table, so I suspect either TIMING ON is not that high an
> overhead on your machine, or the results are that of EXPLAIN ANALYZE.
>
> It would be really great if you could show the EXPLAIN (ANALYZE,
> TIMING OFF) for query 62. There's a chance that the slowdown comes
> from the additional EXPLAIN ANALYZE timing overhead with the Result
> Cache version.
>
> > The result cache is currently enabled by default. However, if this
> > kind of performance regression is common, we have to change its
> > default behavior.
>
> Yes, the feedback we get during the beta period will help drive that
> decision or if the costing needs to be adjusted.
>
> David
SET
QUERY PLAN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Limit (cost=2816266.54..2816267.79 rows=100 width=110) (actual rows=100
loops=1)
-> Sort (cost=2816266.54..2816267.38 rows=336 width=110) (actual rows=100
loops=1)
Sort Key: (substr((warehouse.w_warehouse_name)::text, 1, 20)),
ship_mode.sm_type, web_site.web_name
Sort Method: top-N heapsort Memory: 49kB
-> HashAggregate (cost=2816248.24..2816252.44 rows=336 width=110)
(actual rows=360 loops=1)
Group Key: substr((warehouse.w_warehouse_name)::text, 1, 20),
ship_mode.sm_type, web_site.web_name
Batches: 1 Memory Usage: 157kB
-> Hash Join (cost=2510.74..2794150.54 rows=368295 width=78)
(actual rows=14336926 loops=1)
Hash Cond: (web_sales.ws_ship_mode_sk =
ship_mode.sm_ship_mode_sk)
-> Hash Join (cost=2509.29..2792056.55 rows=368356
width=36) (actual rows=14337390 loops=1)
Hash Cond: (web_sales.ws_web_site_sk =
web_site.web_site_sk)
-> Hash Join (cost=2506.75..2790916.14 rows=368430
width=33) (actual rows=14338265 loops=1)
Hash Cond: (web_sales.ws_warehouse_sk =
warehouse.w_warehouse_sk)
-> Hash Join (cost=2505.41..2789674.19
rows=368516 width=20) (actual rows=14340028 loops=1)
Hash Cond: (web_sales.ws_ship_date_sk =
date_dim.d_date_sk)
-> Seq Scan on web_sales
(cost=0.00..2598153.08 rows=72001808 width=20) (actual rows=72001237 loops=1)
-> Hash (cost=2500.73..2500.73
rows=374 width=4) (actual rows=365 loops=1)
Buckets: 1024 Batches: 1 Memory
Usage: 21kB
-> Seq Scan on date_dim
(cost=0.00..2500.73 rows=374 width=4) (actual rows=365 loops=1)
Filter: ((d_month_seq >=
1212) AND (d_month_seq <= 1223))
Rows Removed by Filter: 72684
-> Hash (cost=1.15..1.15 rows=15 width=21)
(actual rows=15 loops=1)
Buckets: 1024 Batches: 1 Memory Usage:
9kB
-> Seq Scan on warehouse
(cost=0.00..1.15 rows=15 width=21) (actual rows=15 loops=1)
-> Hash (cost=2.24..2.24 rows=24 width=11) (actual
rows=24 loops=1)
Buckets: 1024 Batches: 1 Memory Usage: 10kB
-> Seq Scan on web_site (cost=0.00..2.24
rows=24 width=11) (actual rows=24 loops=1)
-> Hash (cost=1.20..1.20 rows=20 width=35) (actual
rows=20 loops=1)
Buckets: 1024 Batches: 1 Memory Usage: 10kB
-> Seq Scan on ship_mode (cost=0.00..1.20 rows=20
width=35) (actual rows=20 loops=1)
Planning Time: 7.620 ms
Execution Time: 60660.509 ms
(32 rows)
SET
QUERY PLAN
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Limit (cost=2839568.89..2839570.14 rows=100 width=110) (actual rows=100
loops=1)
-> Sort (cost=2839568.89..2839569.73 rows=336 width=110) (actual rows=100
loops=1)
Sort Key: (substr((web_sales.ws_ship_date_sk)::text, 1, 20)),
warehouse.w_warehouse_name, ship_mode.sm_carrier
Sort Method: top-N heapsort Memory: 49kB
-> HashAggregate (cost=2839550.59..2839554.79 rows=336 width=110)
(actual rows=360 loops=1)
Group Key: substr((web_sales.ws_ship_date_sk)::text, 1, 20),
warehouse.w_warehouse_name, ship_mode.sm_carrier
Batches: 1 Memory Usage: 157kB
-> Nested Loop (cost=2505.85..2817452.89 rows=368295 width=78)
(actual rows=14336926 loops=1)
-> Nested Loop (cost=2505.70..2807569.94 rows=368356
width=36) (actual rows=14337390 loops=1)
-> Nested Loop (cost=2505.55..2798567.14
rows=368430 width=33) (actual rows=14338265 loops=1)
-> Hash Join (cost=2505.41..2789674.19
rows=368516 width=20) (actual rows=14340028 loops=1)
Hash Cond: (web_sales.ws_ship_date_sk =
date_dim.d_date_sk)
-> Seq Scan on web_sales
(cost=0.00..2598153.08 rows=72001808 width=20) (actual rows=72001237 loops=1)
-> Hash (cost=2500.73..2500.73
rows=374 width=4) (actual rows=365 loops=1)
Buckets: 1024 Batches: 1 Memory
Usage: 21kB
-> Seq Scan on date_dim
(cost=0.00..2500.73 rows=374 width=4) (actual rows=365 loops=1)
Filter: ((d_month_seq >=
1212) AND (d_month_seq <= 1223))
Rows Removed by Filter: 72684
-> Result Cache (cost=0.15..0.16 rows=1
width=21) (actual rows=1 loops=14340028)
Cache Key: web_sales.ws_warehouse_sk
Hits: 14340012 Misses: 16 Evictions: 0
Overflows: 0 Memory Usage: 2kB
-> Index Scan using warehouse_pkey on
warehouse (cost=0.14..0.15 rows=1 width=21) (actual rows=1 loops=16)
Index Cond: (w_warehouse_sk =
web_sales.ws_warehouse_sk)
-> Result Cache (cost=0.15..0.17 rows=1 width=11)
(actual rows=1 loops=14338265)
Cache Key: web_sales.ws_web_site_sk
Hits: 14338248 Misses: 17 Evictions: 0
Overflows: 0 Memory Usage: 2kB
-> Index Scan using web_site_pkey on web_site
(cost=0.14..0.16 rows=1 width=11) (actual rows=1 loops=17)
Index Cond: (web_site_sk =
web_sales.ws_web_site_sk)
-> Result Cache (cost=0.15..0.17 rows=1 width=35)
(actual rows=1 loops=14337390)
Cache Key: web_sales.ws_ship_mode_sk
Hits: 14337369 Misses: 21 Evictions: 0 Overflows:
0 Memory Usage: 3kB
-> Index Scan using ship_mode_pkey on ship_mode
(cost=0.14..0.16 rows=1 width=35) (actual rows=1 loops=21)
Index Cond: (sm_ship_mode_sk =
web_sales.ws_ship_mode_sk)
Planning Time: 10.396 ms
Execution Time: 66142.932 ms
(35 rows)
SET
Timing is on.
substr | sm_type | web_name | 30 days |
31-60 days | 61-90 days | 91-120 days | >120 days
----------------------+--------------------------------+----------+---------+------------+------------+-------------+-----------
Bad cards must make. | EXPRESS | site_0 | 11835 |
11998 | 11919 | 11881 | 0
Bad cards must make. | EXPRESS | site_1 | 12030 |
12272 | 11959 | 11921 | 0
Bad cards must make. | EXPRESS | site_2 | 11991 |
11946 | 11745 | 11948 | 0
Bad cards must make. | EXPRESS | site_3 | 12050 |
11889 | 11857 | 12016 | 0
Bad cards must make. | LIBRARY | site_0 | 9057 |
8923 | 8827 | 8810 | 0
Bad cards must make. | LIBRARY | site_1 | 9107 |
8838 | 8925 | 8954 | 0
Bad cards must make. | LIBRARY | site_2 | 8915 |
8995 | 9007 | 8931 | 0
Bad cards must make. | LIBRARY | site_3 | 9165 |
8965 | 8936 | 8743 | 0
Bad cards must make. | NEXT DAY | site_0 | 11891 |
11959 | 11895 | 12070 | 0
Bad cards must make. | NEXT DAY | site_1 | 11843 |
12088 | 12045 | 12027 | 0
Bad cards must make. | NEXT DAY | site_2 | 11894 |
12038 | 11736 | 12108 | 0
Bad cards must make. | NEXT DAY | site_3 | 11852 |
11823 | 11836 | 12071 | 0
Bad cards must make. | OVERNIGHT | site_0 | 8859 |
8850 | 9016 | 8944 | 0
Bad cards must make. | OVERNIGHT | site_1 | 9113 |
8709 | 8939 | 8985 | 0
Bad cards must make. | OVERNIGHT | site_2 | 9067 |
8917 | 9297 | 8831 | 0
Bad cards must make. | OVERNIGHT | site_3 | 8881 |
8898 | 8980 | 8790 | 0
Bad cards must make. | REGULAR | site_0 | 9048 |
9043 | 9044 | 8833 | 0
Bad cards must make. | REGULAR | site_1 | 9064 |
8795 | 9005 | 8974 | 0
Bad cards must make. | REGULAR | site_2 | 9198 |
8883 | 8981 | 8858 | 0
Bad cards must make. | REGULAR | site_3 | 8915 |
8971 | 9069 | 9001 | 0
Bad cards must make. | TWO DAY | site_0 | 8904 |
9035 | 9042 | 9109 | 0
Bad cards must make. | TWO DAY | site_1 | 9246 |
8889 | 8848 | 8948 | 0
Bad cards must make. | TWO DAY | site_2 | 9229 |
8899 | 8918 | 8810 | 0
Bad cards must make. | TWO DAY | site_3 | 8968 |
8984 | 9109 | 8848 | 0
Conventional childr | EXPRESS | site_0 | 12172 |
11914 | 11988 | 12019 | 0
Conventional childr | EXPRESS | site_1 | 12053 |
11806 | 11966 | 11878 | 0
Conventional childr | EXPRESS | site_2 | 12026 |
12137 | 11956 | 12029 | 0
Conventional childr | EXPRESS | site_3 | 12175 |
11877 | 11981 | 11852 | 0
Conventional childr | LIBRARY | site_0 | 8951 |
9128 | 8945 | 8916 | 0
Conventional childr | LIBRARY | site_1 | 8814 |
8998 | 9104 | 8981 | 0
Conventional childr | LIBRARY | site_2 | 9057 |
8996 | 9016 | 8944 | 0
Conventional childr | LIBRARY | site_3 | 8981 |
9035 | 8983 | 9045 | 0
Conventional childr | NEXT DAY | site_0 | 11990 |
11939 | 12016 | 11905 | 0
Conventional childr | NEXT DAY | site_1 | 11934 |
12050 | 11962 | 12076 | 0
Conventional childr | NEXT DAY | site_2 | 11946 |
11827 | 12035 | 11856 | 0
Conventional childr | NEXT DAY | site_3 | 12050 |
11954 | 11991 | 11783 | 0
Conventional childr | OVERNIGHT | site_0 | 9005 |
8850 | 8982 | 9050 | 0
Conventional childr | OVERNIGHT | site_1 | 9086 |
9031 | 8887 | 9126 | 0
Conventional childr | OVERNIGHT | site_2 | 8861 |
8833 | 8961 | 9101 | 0
Conventional childr | OVERNIGHT | site_3 | 9046 |
9096 | 8983 | 8954 | 0
Conventional childr | REGULAR | site_0 | 8874 |
8975 | 8961 | 8965 | 0
Conventional childr | REGULAR | site_1 | 8722 |
8931 | 8904 | 8831 | 0
Conventional childr | REGULAR | site_2 | 8954 |
8843 | 8925 | 8840 | 0
Conventional childr | REGULAR | site_3 | 9103 |
8975 | 8947 | 8863 | 0
Conventional childr | TWO DAY | site_0 | 8816 |
8946 | 8994 | 9031 | 0
Conventional childr | TWO DAY | site_1 | 8741 |
8945 | 8859 | 8856 | 0
Conventional childr | TWO DAY | site_2 | 8803 |
9012 | 8985 | 8968 | 0
Conventional childr | TWO DAY | site_3 | 8773 |
9039 | 9035 | 8951 | 0
Doors canno | EXPRESS | site_0 | 11776 |
12009 | 11911 | 11775 | 0
Doors canno | EXPRESS | site_1 | 11979 |
12147 | 12002 | 12194 | 0
Doors canno | EXPRESS | site_2 | 11830 |
11918 | 11960 | 12054 | 0
Doors canno | EXPRESS | site_3 | 12112 |
11805 | 11931 | 12006 | 0
Doors canno | LIBRARY | site_0 | 8930 |
9049 | 9018 | 8752 | 0
Doors canno | LIBRARY | site_1 | 8945 |
9109 | 8937 | 8979 | 0
Doors canno | LIBRARY | site_2 | 8914 |
8827 | 9129 | 9040 | 0
Doors canno | LIBRARY | site_3 | 9028 |
9054 | 9063 | 8985 | 0
Doors canno | NEXT DAY | site_0 | 11990 |
11958 | 12047 | 11761 | 0
Doors canno | NEXT DAY | site_1 | 12107 |
11975 | 11936 | 11914 | 0
Doors canno | NEXT DAY | site_2 | 12013 |
11843 | 11916 | 12030 | 0
Doors canno | NEXT DAY | site_3 | 12067 |
12083 | 12015 | 11778 | 0
Doors canno | OVERNIGHT | site_0 | 8882 |
8911 | 8922 | 8882 | 0
Doors canno | OVERNIGHT | site_1 | 9017 |
8882 | 8972 | 8995 | 0
Doors canno | OVERNIGHT | site_2 | 9040 |
8884 | 8896 | 8976 | 0
Doors canno | OVERNIGHT | site_3 | 9076 |
8978 | 8958 | 8798 | 0
Doors canno | REGULAR | site_0 | 8904 |
8907 | 9045 | 9069 | 0
Doors canno | REGULAR | site_1 | 8972 |
8961 | 8908 | 8897 | 0
Doors canno | REGULAR | site_2 | 8986 |
8981 | 8936 | 8863 | 0
Doors canno | REGULAR | site_3 | 8834 |
8976 | 8808 | 9014 | 0
Doors canno | TWO DAY | site_0 | 8811 |
8965 | 8998 | 8996 | 0
Doors canno | TWO DAY | site_1 | 8915 |
9008 | 8928 | 8944 | 0
Doors canno | TWO DAY | site_2 | 9063 |
8867 | 8886 | 8977 | 0
Doors canno | TWO DAY | site_3 | 9083 |
9020 | 8983 | 9099 | 0
Friendly, suitable | EXPRESS | site_0 | 12162 |
12022 | 12015 | 11960 | 0
Friendly, suitable | EXPRESS | site_1 | 11836 |
11847 | 11897 | 12034 | 0
Friendly, suitable | EXPRESS | site_2 | 12052 |
11952 | 12122 | 11924 | 0
Friendly, suitable | EXPRESS | site_3 | 11936 |
11739 | 11918 | 11648 | 0
Friendly, suitable | LIBRARY | site_0 | 9049 |
9031 | 8996 | 8939 | 0
Friendly, suitable | LIBRARY | site_1 | 8984 |
9018 | 8947 | 8836 | 0
Friendly, suitable | LIBRARY | site_2 | 9037 |
9038 | 8947 | 9192 | 0
Friendly, suitable | LIBRARY | site_3 | 8949 |
8931 | 8842 | 9036 | 0
Friendly, suitable | NEXT DAY | site_0 | 11870 |
11828 | 11856 | 11717 | 0
Friendly, suitable | NEXT DAY | site_1 | 12125 |
11768 | 12078 | 11822 | 0
Friendly, suitable | NEXT DAY | site_2 | 12209 |
11912 | 12014 | 11965 | 0
Friendly, suitable | NEXT DAY | site_3 | 12027 |
11846 | 12107 | 12240 | 0
Friendly, suitable | OVERNIGHT | site_0 | 8898 |
9001 | 8926 | 9175 | 0
Friendly, suitable | OVERNIGHT | site_1 | 8841 |
8851 | 8921 | 9057 | 0
Friendly, suitable | OVERNIGHT | site_2 | 8939 |
8943 | 8941 | 9096 | 0
Friendly, suitable | OVERNIGHT | site_3 | 8720 |
8895 | 9044 | 9098 | 0
Friendly, suitable | REGULAR | site_0 | 8905 |
9121 | 8946 | 8904 | 0
Friendly, suitable | REGULAR | site_1 | 8994 |
8931 | 8922 | 8990 | 0
Friendly, suitable | REGULAR | site_2 | 8940 |
9163 | 8965 | 9057 | 0
Friendly, suitable | REGULAR | site_3 | 8968 |
9001 | 8956 | 9070 | 0
Friendly, suitable | TWO DAY | site_0 | 8865 |
9019 | 8955 | 8858 | 0
Friendly, suitable | TWO DAY | site_1 | 9074 |
9101 | 8756 | 8888 | 0
Friendly, suitable | TWO DAY | site_2 | 8757 |
8929 | 8874 | 8997 | 0
Friendly, suitable | TWO DAY | site_3 | 8943 |
9184 | 8831 | 8978 | 0
Important dem | EXPRESS | site_0 | 11904 |
12162 | 11749 | 11866 | 0
Important dem | EXPRESS | site_1 | 11942 |
11964 | 11866 | 11984 | 0
Important dem | EXPRESS | site_2 | 11842 |
11842 | 12015 | 12085 | 0
Important dem | EXPRESS | site_3 | 11770 |
11735 | 11752 | 12042 | 0
(100 rows)
Time: 60955.751 ms (01:00.956)
SET
Timing is on.
substr | sm_type | web_name | 30 days |
31-60 days | 61-90 days | 91-120 days | >120 days
----------------------+--------------------------------+----------+---------+------------+------------+-------------+-----------
Bad cards must make. | EXPRESS | site_0 | 11835 |
11998 | 11919 | 11881 | 0
Bad cards must make. | EXPRESS | site_1 | 12030 |
12272 | 11959 | 11921 | 0
Bad cards must make. | EXPRESS | site_2 | 11991 |
11946 | 11745 | 11948 | 0
Bad cards must make. | EXPRESS | site_3 | 12050 |
11889 | 11857 | 12016 | 0
Bad cards must make. | LIBRARY | site_0 | 9057 |
8923 | 8827 | 8810 | 0
Bad cards must make. | LIBRARY | site_1 | 9107 |
8838 | 8925 | 8954 | 0
Bad cards must make. | LIBRARY | site_2 | 8915 |
8995 | 9007 | 8931 | 0
Bad cards must make. | LIBRARY | site_3 | 9165 |
8965 | 8936 | 8743 | 0
Bad cards must make. | NEXT DAY | site_0 | 11891 |
11959 | 11895 | 12070 | 0
Bad cards must make. | NEXT DAY | site_1 | 11843 |
12088 | 12045 | 12027 | 0
Bad cards must make. | NEXT DAY | site_2 | 11894 |
12038 | 11736 | 12108 | 0
Bad cards must make. | NEXT DAY | site_3 | 11852 |
11823 | 11836 | 12071 | 0
Bad cards must make. | OVERNIGHT | site_0 | 8859 |
8850 | 9016 | 8944 | 0
Bad cards must make. | OVERNIGHT | site_1 | 9113 |
8709 | 8939 | 8985 | 0
Bad cards must make. | OVERNIGHT | site_2 | 9067 |
8917 | 9297 | 8831 | 0
Bad cards must make. | OVERNIGHT | site_3 | 8881 |
8898 | 8980 | 8790 | 0
Bad cards must make. | REGULAR | site_0 | 9048 |
9043 | 9044 | 8833 | 0
Bad cards must make. | REGULAR | site_1 | 9064 |
8795 | 9005 | 8974 | 0
Bad cards must make. | REGULAR | site_2 | 9198 |
8883 | 8981 | 8858 | 0
Bad cards must make. | REGULAR | site_3 | 8915 |
8971 | 9069 | 9001 | 0
Bad cards must make. | TWO DAY | site_0 | 8904 |
9035 | 9042 | 9109 | 0
Bad cards must make. | TWO DAY | site_1 | 9246 |
8889 | 8848 | 8948 | 0
Bad cards must make. | TWO DAY | site_2 | 9229 |
8899 | 8918 | 8810 | 0
Bad cards must make. | TWO DAY | site_3 | 8968 |
8984 | 9109 | 8848 | 0
Conventional childr | EXPRESS | site_0 | 12172 |
11914 | 11988 | 12019 | 0
Conventional childr | EXPRESS | site_1 | 12053 |
11806 | 11966 | 11878 | 0
Conventional childr | EXPRESS | site_2 | 12026 |
12137 | 11956 | 12029 | 0
Conventional childr | EXPRESS | site_3 | 12175 |
11877 | 11981 | 11852 | 0
Conventional childr | LIBRARY | site_0 | 8951 |
9128 | 8945 | 8916 | 0
Conventional childr | LIBRARY | site_1 | 8814 |
8998 | 9104 | 8981 | 0
Conventional childr | LIBRARY | site_2 | 9057 |
8996 | 9016 | 8944 | 0
Conventional childr | LIBRARY | site_3 | 8981 |
9035 | 8983 | 9045 | 0
Conventional childr | NEXT DAY | site_0 | 11990 |
11939 | 12016 | 11905 | 0
Conventional childr | NEXT DAY | site_1 | 11934 |
12050 | 11962 | 12076 | 0
Conventional childr | NEXT DAY | site_2 | 11946 |
11827 | 12035 | 11856 | 0
Conventional childr | NEXT DAY | site_3 | 12050 |
11954 | 11991 | 11783 | 0
Conventional childr | OVERNIGHT | site_0 | 9005 |
8850 | 8982 | 9050 | 0
Conventional childr | OVERNIGHT | site_1 | 9086 |
9031 | 8887 | 9126 | 0
Conventional childr | OVERNIGHT | site_2 | 8861 |
8833 | 8961 | 9101 | 0
Conventional childr | OVERNIGHT | site_3 | 9046 |
9096 | 8983 | 8954 | 0
Conventional childr | REGULAR | site_0 | 8874 |
8975 | 8961 | 8965 | 0
Conventional childr | REGULAR | site_1 | 8722 |
8931 | 8904 | 8831 | 0
Conventional childr | REGULAR | site_2 | 8954 |
8843 | 8925 | 8840 | 0
Conventional childr | REGULAR | site_3 | 9103 |
8975 | 8947 | 8863 | 0
Conventional childr | TWO DAY | site_0 | 8816 |
8946 | 8994 | 9031 | 0
Conventional childr | TWO DAY | site_1 | 8741 |
8945 | 8859 | 8856 | 0
Conventional childr | TWO DAY | site_2 | 8803 |
9012 | 8985 | 8968 | 0
Conventional childr | TWO DAY | site_3 | 8773 |
9039 | 9035 | 8951 | 0
Doors canno | EXPRESS | site_0 | 11776 |
12009 | 11911 | 11775 | 0
Doors canno | EXPRESS | site_1 | 11979 |
12147 | 12002 | 12194 | 0
Doors canno | EXPRESS | site_2 | 11830 |
11918 | 11960 | 12054 | 0
Doors canno | EXPRESS | site_3 | 12112 |
11805 | 11931 | 12006 | 0
Doors canno | LIBRARY | site_0 | 8930 |
9049 | 9018 | 8752 | 0
Doors canno | LIBRARY | site_1 | 8945 |
9109 | 8937 | 8979 | 0
Doors canno | LIBRARY | site_2 | 8914 |
8827 | 9129 | 9040 | 0
Doors canno | LIBRARY | site_3 | 9028 |
9054 | 9063 | 8985 | 0
Doors canno | NEXT DAY | site_0 | 11990 |
11958 | 12047 | 11761 | 0
Doors canno | NEXT DAY | site_1 | 12107 |
11975 | 11936 | 11914 | 0
Doors canno | NEXT DAY | site_2 | 12013 |
11843 | 11916 | 12030 | 0
Doors canno | NEXT DAY | site_3 | 12067 |
12083 | 12015 | 11778 | 0
Doors canno | OVERNIGHT | site_0 | 8882 |
8911 | 8922 | 8882 | 0
Doors canno | OVERNIGHT | site_1 | 9017 |
8882 | 8972 | 8995 | 0
Doors canno | OVERNIGHT | site_2 | 9040 |
8884 | 8896 | 8976 | 0
Doors canno | OVERNIGHT | site_3 | 9076 |
8978 | 8958 | 8798 | 0
Doors canno | REGULAR | site_0 | 8904 |
8907 | 9045 | 9069 | 0
Doors canno | REGULAR | site_1 | 8972 |
8961 | 8908 | 8897 | 0
Doors canno | REGULAR | site_2 | 8986 |
8981 | 8936 | 8863 | 0
Doors canno | REGULAR | site_3 | 8834 |
8976 | 8808 | 9014 | 0
Doors canno | TWO DAY | site_0 | 8811 |
8965 | 8998 | 8996 | 0
Doors canno | TWO DAY | site_1 | 8915 |
9008 | 8928 | 8944 | 0
Doors canno | TWO DAY | site_2 | 9063 |
8867 | 8886 | 8977 | 0
Doors canno | TWO DAY | site_3 | 9083 |
9020 | 8983 | 9099 | 0
Friendly, suitable | EXPRESS | site_0 | 12162 |
12022 | 12015 | 11960 | 0
Friendly, suitable | EXPRESS | site_1 | 11836 |
11847 | 11897 | 12034 | 0
Friendly, suitable | EXPRESS | site_2 | 12052 |
11952 | 12122 | 11924 | 0
Friendly, suitable | EXPRESS | site_3 | 11936 |
11739 | 11918 | 11648 | 0
Friendly, suitable | LIBRARY | site_0 | 9049 |
9031 | 8996 | 8939 | 0
Friendly, suitable | LIBRARY | site_1 | 8984 |
9018 | 8947 | 8836 | 0
Friendly, suitable | LIBRARY | site_2 | 9037 |
9038 | 8947 | 9192 | 0
Friendly, suitable | LIBRARY | site_3 | 8949 |
8931 | 8842 | 9036 | 0
Friendly, suitable | NEXT DAY | site_0 | 11870 |
11828 | 11856 | 11717 | 0
Friendly, suitable | NEXT DAY | site_1 | 12125 |
11768 | 12078 | 11822 | 0
Friendly, suitable | NEXT DAY | site_2 | 12209 |
11912 | 12014 | 11965 | 0
Friendly, suitable | NEXT DAY | site_3 | 12027 |
11846 | 12107 | 12240 | 0
Friendly, suitable | OVERNIGHT | site_0 | 8898 |
9001 | 8926 | 9175 | 0
Friendly, suitable | OVERNIGHT | site_1 | 8841 |
8851 | 8921 | 9057 | 0
Friendly, suitable | OVERNIGHT | site_2 | 8939 |
8943 | 8941 | 9096 | 0
Friendly, suitable | OVERNIGHT | site_3 | 8720 |
8895 | 9044 | 9098 | 0
Friendly, suitable | REGULAR | site_0 | 8905 |
9121 | 8946 | 8904 | 0
Friendly, suitable | REGULAR | site_1 | 8994 |
8931 | 8922 | 8990 | 0
Friendly, suitable | REGULAR | site_2 | 8940 |
9163 | 8965 | 9057 | 0
Friendly, suitable | REGULAR | site_3 | 8968 |
9001 | 8956 | 9070 | 0
Friendly, suitable | TWO DAY | site_0 | 8865 |
9019 | 8955 | 8858 | 0
Friendly, suitable | TWO DAY | site_1 | 9074 |
9101 | 8756 | 8888 | 0
Friendly, suitable | TWO DAY | site_2 | 8757 |
8929 | 8874 | 8997 | 0
Friendly, suitable | TWO DAY | site_3 | 8943 |
9184 | 8831 | 8978 | 0
Important dem | EXPRESS | site_0 | 11904 |
12162 | 11749 | 11866 | 0
Important dem | EXPRESS | site_1 | 11942 |
11964 | 11866 | 11984 | 0
Important dem | EXPRESS | site_2 | 11842 |
11842 | 12015 | 12085 | 0
Important dem | EXPRESS | site_3 | 11770 |
11735 | 11752 | 12042 | 0
(100 rows)
Time: 66611.049 ms (01:06.611)
