Scott Carey wrote: > On 10/3/09 7:35 PM, "Karl Denninger" <k...@denninger.net> wrote: > > >> I am a particular fan of FreeBSD, and in some benchmarking I did between it >> and CentOS FreeBSD 7.x literally wiped the floor with the CentOS release I >> tried on IDENTICAL hardware. >> I also like the 3ware raid coprocessors - they work well, are fast, and I've >> had zero trouble with them. >> >> -- Karl >> > > With CentOS 5.x, I have to do quite a bit of tuning to get it to perform > well. I often get almost 2x the performance after tuning. > > For I/O -- > Deadline scheduler + reasonably large block device read-ahead + XFS > configured with large 'allocsize' settings (8MB to 80MB) make a huge > difference. > > Furthermore, the 3ware 35xx and 36xx (I think) I tried performed > particularly badly out of the box without tuning on CentOS. > > So, Identical hardware or not, both have to be tuned well to really compare > anyway. > > However, I have certainly seen some inefficiencies with Linux and large use > of shared memory -- and I wouldn't be surprised if these problems don't > exist on FreeBSD or OpenSolaris. > I don't run the 3x series 3ware boards. If I recall correctly they're not true coprocessor boards and rely on the host CPU. Those are always going to be a lose compared to a true coprocessor with dedicated cache memory on the card.
The 9xxx series boards are, and are extremely fast (make sure you install the battery backup or run on a UPS, set the appropriate flags, and take your chances - writeback caching makes a HUGE difference.) Other than pinning shared memory on FreeBSD (and increasing a couple of boot-time tunables to permit large enough shared segments and semaphore lists) little is required to get excellent performance. The LSI cards that DELL, Intel and a few others have used (these appear to be deprecated now as it looks like LSI bought 3ware) also work well but their user interface is somewhat of a pain in the butt compared to 3Ware's. -- Karl
<<attachment: karl.vcf>>
-- Sent via pgsql-performance mailing list (pgsql-performance@postgresql.org) To make changes to your subscription: http://www.postgresql.org/mailpref/pgsql-performance
