Hello all,

I'm running into an issue when joining between to tables that are partitioned 
by month. At this point I'm leaning towards it being a bug in the planner but 
it could be due to something I'm not doing properly as well. Each parent table 
is empty and has about 30 child tables, and there are between 2 and 10 mil rows 
total in each set of partitions. When selecting a particular day's data, 
indexes and constraint exclusion are used if queried individually and the 
results return in under a second. However, querying from the two tables 
inner/natural joined together with a single day in the where clause results in 
a full sequential scan on the second table, so the query takes a ridiculous 
amount of time. Changing the order of the tables in the join changes which 
table is fully scanned.

All child tables have been recently vacuum analyzed. I've played around with 
this every which way, and not been able to get the planner to make a more 
reasonable decision. I have several different boxes with varying physical specs 
running either CentOS 5.8 or 6.4, and Postgres 8.4.17, and they all exhibit the 
same behavior, so I've ruled out the possibility that it's related to a 
particular quirk in one database. I didn't notice the issue at first because 
the tables weren't large enough for it to cause any serious performance issues. 
Now that the tables have grown, queries involving a join no longer finish in 
any reasonable number of hours.

I've been able to reproduce the issue in a generic environment and posted the 
code to create this environment on my GitHub at 
https://github.com/mikeokner/pgsql_test. The query plans demonstrating this 
issue are pasted here: http://bpaste.net/show/92138/. I've poked around on IRC 
and no one seems to think this is normal behavior. Is it in fact a bug or is 
there something I should be doing to fix this behavior?

Regards,
Mike

Reply via email to