ID: 44367 User updated by: daniel dot oconnor at gmail dot com Reported By: daniel dot oconnor at gmail dot com Status: Bogus Bug Type: DOM XML related Operating System: Windows PHP Version: 5.2.5 Assigned To: rrichards New Comment:
:S I hate being pushy / argumentitive, sorry if its coming across that way. RFC 2396 is "Uniform Resource Identifiers (URI): Generic Syntax" Section 5.1. is "Establishing a Base URI" describes what I've been trying to say, probably a little clearer. XML Base spec @ http://www.w3.org/TR/xmlbase/#rfc2396 says: Determine a baseURI: 1. The base URI is embedded in the document's content. 2. The base URI is that of the encapsulating entity (message, document, or none). 3. The base URI is the URI used to retrieve the entity. 4. The base URI is defined by the context of the application. > This is not just how it is implemented in PHP as the other major DOM parsers implement it the same way ... and that's why the xml:base GRDDL tests were written - to clarify correct behaviour / check implementations. Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2008-03-12 17:16:05] [EMAIL PROTECTED] still bogus as what you are describing pertains to GRDDL only not DOM, so when working with GRDDL and DOm you need to check base uri of the document element, not the DOMDocument. DOM determines base uri using the xml base spec. "The base URI of a document entity or an external entity is determined by RFC 2396 rules, namely, that the base URI is the URI used to retrieve the document entity or external entity." This is not just how it is implemented in PHP as the other major DOM parsers implement it the same way, ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2008-03-11 00:03:46] daniel dot oconnor at gmail dot com See http://www.w3.org/TR/grddl/#base_misc & http://www.apps.ietf.org/rfc/rfc3986.html#sec-5.1 The way to determine baseURI is: 1. Look for it on the root document element (HTML - <base>, XML - <foo xml:base=""> 2. Couldn't find that? Use the URL we retrieved the document with * And make sure we follow redirects! 3. Couldn't find that? Application specific (but we don't really have a setBaseURI()) So, condition #1 is broken in 5.2.5 when you do: <?php $doc = DOMDocument::load('http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/inline-rdf6.xml'); var_dump($doc->baseURI); //Expected http://wwww.example.org/ produces: string(53) "http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/inline-rdf6.xml"; ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2008-03-10 14:09:30] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Thank you for taking the time to write to us, but this is not a bug. Please double-check the documentation available at http://www.php.net/manual/ and the instructions on how to report a bug at http://bugs.php.net/how-to-report.php Don't know about GRDDL, but for DOM trees, base uri of a DOMDocument is the URI its loaded from (or for memory based tree, the current dir). You need to check on the document element to get the base uri you are looking for. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2008-03-08 22:20:31] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Rob, please take a look ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2008-03-08 05:09:06] daniel dot oconnor at gmail dot com Description: ------------ The W3C clarified a few xml:base issues when publishing the GRDDL spec. You can see the tests at http://www.w3.org/TR/grddl-tests/#ambiguous-infoset. Basically: * DOMDocument::loadXML does not detect xml:base attributes * simplexml_load_file does not detect xml:base attributes (or they are lost during the importNode phase) * simplexml_load_string does not detect xml:base attributes (or they are lost during the importNode phase) * DOMDocument does not deal with nested xml:base * DOMDocument does not deal with redirected xml:base locations To clarify on the redirect-xml:base stuff... If I request http://foo.com/example.xml and that redirects me to http://bar.com/example.xml and bar.com/example.xml said xml:base = http://foo.com/example.xml ... then http://bar.com/example.xml's baseURI should be http://bar.com/example.xml Reproduce code: --------------- <?php $url = 'http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/base/xmlWithBase.xml'; $xml = file_get_contents($url); //Load a url $doc = DOMDocument::load($url); var_dump($doc->baseURI); //Expected http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/base/xmlWithBase.xml //Load an xml document with xml:base $doc = DOMDocument::loadXML($xml); var_dump($doc->baseURI); //Expected http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/base/xmlWithBase.xml //Does it work with importNode? $sxe = simplexml_load_file($url); $dom_sxe = dom_import_simplexml($sxe); $dom = new DOMDocument('1.0'); $dom_sxe = $dom->importNode($dom_sxe, true); $dom_sxe = $dom->appendChild($dom_sxe); var_dump($doc->baseURI); //Expected (maybe) http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/base/xmlWithBase.xml // Alternative? $sxe = simplexml_load_string($xml); $dom_sxe = dom_import_simplexml($sxe); $dom = new DOMDocument('1.0'); $dom_sxe = $dom->importNode($dom_sxe, true); $dom_sxe = $dom->appendChild($dom_sxe); var_dump($doc->baseURI); //Expected (maybe) http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/base/xmlWithBase.xml //What about documents with an invalid xml:base (not on the top level element)? $doc = DOMDocument::load('http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/inline-rdf6.xml'); var_dump($doc->baseURI); //Expected http://wwww.example.org/ //What about documents with a *redirected xml:base* ? //Note: this test case is a little broken because of a W3C server change - it *should* redirect to 'http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/base/xmlWithBase.xml' // and thus have a funky new xml:base value $doc = DOMDocument::load('http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/xmlWithBase.xml'); var_dump($doc->baseURI); //Expected http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/base/xmlWithBase.xml Expected result: ---------------- See reproduce code Actual result: -------------- See reproduce code ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=44367&edit=1
