ID: 48695 User updated by: allerlei+bugs dot php dot net at sihw dot nl Reported By: allerlei+bugs dot php dot net at sihw dot nl Status: Open Bug Type: CGI related Operating System: Centos 4/5 PHP Version: 5.2.10 New Comment:
Bug #47625 was closed as bogus (because it would be the same as bug #47042) but it is not. In version 5.2.10 at least, PHP_SELF and SCRIPT_FILENAME are set based on the ORIG_SCRIPTNAME, while in version 5.2.8 these are based on SCRIPT_NAME. So bug #47042 fixes some bug, but introduces a new one. Therefore this is not a duplicate bug. It is not bogus because the values of PHP_SELF etc changed between 5.2.8 and 5.2.10 without this being part of the specification for 5.2.10. It breaks a lot of code on my systems, including phpmyadmin and joomla. Problem is that PHP_SELF should refer to the URL before the internal redirect or external handler. This is a problematic requirement because of all the jugling with SCRIPTNAME and ORIG_SCRIPTNAME, but bug #47625 described the bug exactly. The problem might me in the naming: handlers put the redirection into ORIG_SCRIPTNAME and the original path in SCRIPTNAME. I use a handler called startscript that is called with some pathinfo like /../startscript/php/myuser/path/to/script/. So the path /centraal/scripts/info.php when called from a vsite owned by user jelmer, is rewritten to /usr/bin/startscript/php/jelmer/scripts/info.php but PHP_SELF should remain /centraal/scripts/info.php Thank you for your thougths, Jelmer Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2009-06-25 14:22:35] allerlei+bugs dot php dot net at sihw dot nl Description: ------------ Bug #47625 was closed as bogus (because it would be the same as bug #47042) but it is not. In version 5.2.10 at least, PHP_SELF and SCRIPT_FILENAME are set based on the ORIG_SCRIPTNAME, while in version 5.2.8 these are based on SCRIPT_NAME. So bug #47042 fixes some bug, but introduces a new one. Therefore this is not a duplicate bug. It is not bogus because the values of PHP_SELF etc changed betwoon 5.2.10 without this being part of the specification for 5.2.10. It breaks a lot of code on my systems, including phpmyadmin and joomla. Problem is that PHP_SELF should refer to the URL before the internal redirect or external handler. This is a problematic requirement because of all the jugling with SCRIPTNAME and ORIG_SCRIPTNAME, but bug #47625 described the bug exactly. The problem might me in the naming: handlers put the redirection into ORIG_SCRIPTNAME and the original path in SCRIPTNAME. I use a handler called startscript that is called with some pathinfo like /../startscript/php/myuser/path/to/script/. So the path /centraal/scripts/info.php when called from a vsite owned by user jelmer, is rewritten to /usr/bin/startscript/php/jelmer/scripts/info.php but PHP_SELF should remain /centraal/scripts/info.php Thank you for your thougths, Jelmer ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=48695&edit=1
