Ilia,

I appreciate your continious effort about QC process.
GPC bug in rfc1867.c is not critical one, and I agree with you 
it is not preferable in the final RC process.
I will revert my GPC related patch in a couple of hours.

But, I shoudn't revert an another license related patch 
as shown below because the license compatibility has priority.

+2003-10-25  Rui Hirokawa  <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
+
+    * (PHP_4_3)
+      ext/mbstring/mbstring.dsp:
+      fixed windows build.
+
+    * (PHP_4_3)
+      ext/mbstring/README.libmbfl
+      ext/mbstring/config.m4
+      ext/mbstring/cp932_table.h
+      ext/mbstring/html_entities.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter.h
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_cn.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_cn.h
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_ja.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_ja.h
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_kr.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_kr.h
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_ru.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_ru.h
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_tw.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbfilter_tw.h
+      ext/mbstring/mbregex.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbregex.h
+      ext/mbstring/mbstring.c
+      ext/mbstring/mbstring.dsp
+      ext/mbstring/mbstring.h
+      ext/mbstring/unicode_table.h
+      ext/mbstring/unicode_table_cn.h
+      ext/mbstring/unicode_table_ja.h
+      ext/mbstring/unicode_table_kr.h
+      ext/mbstring/unicode_table_ru.h
+      ext/mbstring/unicode_table_tw.h:
+      mbfilter is replaced with libmbfl to maintain the licence compatibility.
+      mbregex.[ch] is moved to mbregex/ for the same reason.
+

On Sun, 26 Oct 2003 00:46:29 -0400
Ilia Alshanetsky <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> On October 25, 2003 07:14 pm, Rasmus Lerdorf wrote:
> > Ah, thought it was the other patch.  However, I wouldn't call the above a
> > new feature.  That one is a bug fix as it was an oversight to not also
> > convert form fields in multipart posts.
> 
> Well, it is a mix of a feature & a bug fix. The bug if we decide to call it 
> such is by no means critical and 2 days before the release time is not a time 
> to make any non critical changes simply because there is no time to test 
> them.  rfc1867.c is very sensitive code which previously had a number of 
> security faults at least 1 directly caused by mbstring related changes. It is 
> my opinion such changes have no place this late in the release cycle.
> 
> Ilia


-- 
Rui Hirokawa <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

-- 
PHP CVS Mailing List (http://www.php.net/)
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php

Reply via email to