From:             [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Operating system: Solaris 7
PHP version:      4.0.4
PHP Bug Type:     Math related
Bug description:  rand() or getrandmax() is broken

I'm in the middle of porting a php-3.0.16 website to php-4.0.4, and have
run into a minor snafu. There seems to be a difference between what rand() can use, 
and what getrandmax() reports. The difference seems to lie in one
function using RAND_MAX and the other using PHP_RAND_MAX.

In php_rand.h the #if HAVE_LRAND48 is satisfied, therefore PHP_RAND_MAX gets set to 
2147483647,  instead of the system default of
32767 set in /usr/include/stdlib.h. I notice in php-3.0.16 the PHP_RAND_MAX value of 
2147483647 is the one that gets used across the board. Would it cause instability to 
substitute PHP_RAND_MAX for RAND_MAX on line 246 of ext/standard/rand.c?


When I do:

  $randnum = rand(1,99999);

It produces the following result:

<b>Warning</b>:  rand():  Invalid range:  1..99999 in 
<b>/WWW/</b> on line <b>537</b><br>

A call to getrandmax(); produces the result of 2147483647 

line 246 of ext/standard/rand.c uses RAND_MAX

 }else if ((*p_max)->value.lval-(*p_min)->value.lval > RA

line 346 of ext/standard/rand.c uses PHP_RAND_MAX

        return_value->value.lval = PHP_RAND_MAX;


Edit Bug report at:

PHP Development Mailing List <>
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To contact the list administrators, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to