ID: 12623
Updated by: jmcastagnetto
Old Status: Open
Status: Closed
Bug Type: Math related
Operating System: linux (suse)
PHP Version: 4.0.4pl1
New Comment:

The modulus operator is strictly defined for integer numbers, because it "... 
basically just returns the remainder of an integer division operation ..." 
(paraphrasing from the K&R book)

In this case the floats are truncated to integers and then the modulus operator is 
applied, i.e.

203.5 turns into 203
17.9 turns into 17

then 203 % 17 = 16 (as expected)

Other languages follow this approach, while other round up the float previous to 
operating on them, in those languages the result would be: "6"

And other languages, like Java, have a third behavior in which when using floats, a 
number of integer substractions is made and a floating point reminder is calculated, 
see for example:,,12079_630791,00.html
(explanation to question 3)

BTW, gawk also performs an integer number of substractions, if you try:

gawk '{ print (203.5 % 17.9) }'

you'll get "6.6"

Bottomline, as this is an operator meant to work with integers, make the appropriate 
conversion for the appropriate results, or implement a modulus function like:

function modulus_of ($q, $d) {
  $rem = $q;
  while ($rem > $d )
     $rem -= $d;
  return $rem;

which *will* return "6.6" for floats, and should also work on integers.

Previous Comments:

[2001-08-07 11:14:21] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Modulus (%) operator
i am not sure if the behavior for non-integer operands is defined, so i am not sure 
how important this actually is

2035 % 179 = 66      // correct!

203.5 % 17.9 = 16    // incorrect - should be 6.6!

  echo  "2035 % 179 == " . 2035 % 179;
  echo "<br>\n";
  echo  "203.5 % 17.9 == " . 203.5 % 17.9;


Edit this bug report at

PHP Development Mailing List <>
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To contact the list administrators, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to