* Rich Burridge <[email protected]> [2009-03-16 22:02]:
> Hi,
>
> Here's a second webrev for the package renaming for the unbundleds
> packages:
>
> http://cr.opensolaris.org/~richb/pkg-6941-v2
>
> Based on Stephen's feedback to the bug report:
>
> http://defect.opensolaris.org/bz/show_bug.cgi?id=6941#c3
>
> I've made the following changes:
>
> clustertools_7.1 ==> develop/clustertools-71
> clustertools_8.1 ==> develop/clustertools-81
> glassfishv2 ==> web/glassfish-v2
> mq41 ==> service/network/message-queue-41
>
> I didn't see a reply to Shawn's question about what should be done
> with the glassfish name, so it's now web/glassfish-v2. The rest are
> as described in the previously attached email below.
unbundleds/DTraceGUI:
6. develop/ide/netbeans/ide. Why "develop/ide/netbeans" and not
just "develop/netbeans"? How populated do you expect the ide
subset to be?
16. develop/ide/netbeans/dtrace/gui-plugin. "gui-plugin" is a bad
package basename, since it is non-specific. Either
"dtrace-gui-plugin" or "dtrace-gui".
unbundleds/Eclipse:
*. Same as for the NetBeans naming. If there are only two - four
IDEs, and they are all significant, why not just have them
top-level within develop/?
unbundleds/GlassFishV2:
1. I don't really think we need both "-[number]" and "-v[number]"
conventions. So "glassfish-2".
unbundleds/MessageQueue41:
3. Hard to figure out the right category for this one. It's not
really a system service.
unbundleds/NetBeans:
*. What's the difference between a component in
develop/ide/netbeans/library/ and a component that's in
develop/ide/netbeans?
25. I don't think we want "incorporation" as a basename. Does
installing this package allow NetBeans to update its own
components?
unbundleds/OpenDS:
1. I think this package and MessageQueue41 should be nearby in the
category space. A server shouldn't generally be in a library
category, for instance. Maybe system/network/naming/opends?
2. Not sure I like this category, but don't have a better
suggestion.
unbundleds/OpenOffice:
1. Not a system package. Looking at your full fix, I would suggest
either command/openoffice or maybe editor/openoffice.
unbundleds/Studio:
1. Drop "ide", unless we come up with a good reason to keep it.
unbundles/Webstackui:
1. Is there a better name than "webstackui"? Would "webstack-gui"
be better, given "dtrace-gui"? (That is, should "-gui" be the
standard suffix for graphical wrappers?)
Thanks for working this out.
- Stephen
_______________________________________________
pkg-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/pkg-discuss
