clone 982635 -1
clone 982635 -2
clone 982635 -3
clone 982635 -4
retitle -1 libcommons-lang-java: Replace d/.mh_clean with debian/clean
retitle -2 maven-debian-helper: Replace d/.mh_clean with debian/clean
retitle -3 maven-repo-helper: mh_clean can be made redundant
retitle -4 maven-repo-helper: Provide dh-sequence-maven-repo-helper
block -3 by -2
block -3 by -1
reassign -1 libcommons-lang-java
reassign -2 maven-debian-helper
reassign -3 maven-repo-helper
reassign -4 maven-repo-helper
thanks

Hi Java maintainers,


To facilitate bootstrapping, it would be great if the maven-repo-helper
debhelper add-on could support being a "conditional add-on".  This would
enable packages to move their dependency on maven repo helper to
Build-Depends-Indep.

For this to be possible, we need to do two things:

 1) The maven-repo-helper must provide dh-sequence-maven-repo-helper,
    which packages should then use in their Build-Depends(-Indep).
    - This would also enable them to remove the
      "--with maven-repo-helper" boilerlate from their debian/rules.

 2) The maven-repo-helper must *not* change the "clean" target, which
    it currently does due to "mh_clean".

The first item can be done already "now" (mind the freeze) but the
second item will require some changes to 3 packages, which I will expand
on here.

# Usage of mh_clean

Using codesearch, I have narrowed the use of mh_clean down into 3 cases
that we need to fix (I cloned this bug for each of these cases).

 1) libcommons-lang-java uses debian/.mh_clean to register a generated
    file it wants cleaned.  This use can trivially be replaced by adding
    the filename to debian/clean and removing the use debian/.mh_clean.

 2) maven-debian-helper has a similar history except it creates a
    directory beneath debian/.mh to generate some manpages.  Here I
    would change the directory (e.g. "generated-manpages") and add
    the directory to debian/clean (with a trailing slash).

 3) maven-repo-helper uses debian/.mh internally between its mh_*
    commands.  If maven-repo-helper instead uses debian/.debhelper/_mh
    (or debian/.debhelper/_maven-repo-helper) then debhelper will
    handle the clean up automatically.

Once all three items have been resolved, maven-repo-helper no longer
needs mh_clean AFAICT.  Combined with the new Provides, then Helmut will
be able to move some uses of maven-repo-helper to Build-Depends-Indep
and reduce the number of packages involved in bootstrapping Debian.


Thanks,
~Niels

__
This is the maintainer address of Debian's Java team
<https://alioth-lists.debian.net/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/pkg-java-maintainers>.
 Please use
debian-j...@lists.debian.org for discussions and questions.

Reply via email to