On Tue, 2010-11-09 at 18:51 -0300, Felipe Sateler wrote: > On Mon, Nov 8, 2010 at 20:24, Hans-Christoph Steiner <h...@at.or.at> wrote: > > > > Hey all, > > > > So I've been threatening with all those ITPs, now here's some more > > delivery ;). Here are a slew of short-form DH Pd library packages in > > two major families: simple and not-simple. They are all looking for > > sponsors :) > > > > simple > > ------ > > pd-ekext > > Uploaded. Please for the next upload inlude some text on pd and > puredata in the long description (that way if I search for pure data I > can find it). This comment applies for all pd libraries.
Thank you! > > pd-pan > > Please update the changelog when updating the package. The timestamp > helps people tell when was the last time someone worked on a package. > Also the long description is too short Updated changelog and description and pushed. > > pd-purepd > > I don't get the point of this package. Why reimplement builtin pd > objects in pd? Also, it depends on pd-list-abs which does not exist > yet. Pd patches are scripts rather than binaries so having things implemented in Pd means you can bundle them with a project and they'll work on any platform. Also, those objects are not re-implementing objects built into the core of Pd, but rather from other libraries. This library is a dependency for a few other libraries as well. pd-list-abs is almost done, just waiting on final sign-off from the upstream author. I guess all new packages with interdependencies need to be uploaded all together? > > not-simple (have patches and other oddities) > > -------------------------------------------- > > pd-ext13 > > Please update the changelog. And provide some explanation on what does > it actually do in the short and long descriptions. The git repository > is dirty with debhelper files. Done. I also added linux-libc-dev as a Build-Dep since the package uses linux/cdrom.h and linux/soundcard.h. I hope this makes sense. > > pd-hcs > > Again, the changelog. It depends on pd-cyclone which is not on debian > yet. pd-cyclone and pd-unauthorized are in the works, they are both dependencies of packages that I have uploaded to git.debian.org. > It also depends on pd-purepd, why? can't it use the pd builtins? It uses hard-coded names to purepd objects, that's why there is the Depends. And it uses objects that are not in 'puredata', so it doesn't really matter if its from pd-purepd or another, there will need to be a Depends. > The lintian override in this case is not worth working around IMO (the > image-file-in-usr-lib one). Just override it. Also, in the long > description please elaborate on the objects contained in the package. Ok, noted for future packages. I figured there might be some security issue with images in /usr/lib since JPEGs have been known to be exploitable. > > pd-pddp > > The changelog needs to be updated. There is no need for the BSD file > reference, it will be going away, and you already copied the entire > license. Same comment on the lintian warning as in the prevoius > package. Updated timestamp in changelog. > > pd-moonlib > > Not in the git repository yet. It is now... sorry about that. > I've been thinking: all packages need to do the same fiddling with the > license and the shlibdeps thingy. Would it be possible to abstract > this in a makefile snippet? Hopefully one that is not tied to short > form dh. That would be possible, but perhaps a patch to dh_shlibdeps would be the way to do it properly? Here's an updated version of the above list: simple (without new dependencies) -------------------------- pd-bsaylor pd-cxc pd-markex pd-mjlib pd-pan pd-sigpack pd-smlib pd-windowing with patches ------------ pd-ext13 pd-maxlib pd-moonlib pd-pddp pd-pdogg still missing new dependencies ------------------------------ pd-hcs pd-mapping pd-purepd in the works (not uploaded to git.debian.org yet) ------------------------------------------------- pd-cyclone pd-jmmmp pd-list-abs pd-unauthorized .hc _______________________________________________ pkg-multimedia-maintainers mailing list pkg-multimedia-maintainers@lists.alioth.debian.org http://lists.alioth.debian.org/mailman/listinfo/pkg-multimedia-maintainers
