Am 14.08.2019 um 01:24 schrieb rstei...@ensemblesoft.net:
Hi Stephan, Ed, and Lars,
Thanks for the tips and other comments.
I've reviewed the guide you (Stephan) indicated, and in the interests of
avoiding drilling more dry holes, will hold-off trying to execute it
until after getting some answers to the following question 1.:
1. Under "Where is the JDT/Core code?", before any mention of EGit, it
instructs "You need to check out the following projects from
git://git.eclipse.org/gitroot/jdt/eclipse.jdt.core.git". Then under
"How do I create a Git repository connections?", it says "Go through
http://wiki.eclipse.org/Platform-releng/Git_Workflows to see how to
set up Egit and create repository connections." Should this be
understood to apply to all the prior check-outs? If so, may I
suggest that this second section be placed above the first, reducing
the likelihood of wasted effort, self-applied hair removal, and/or
You might be right. On the other hand. On the other hand if you already
managed to "check out the following projects" you won't need the "Git
Workflows" until you want to push a change. :)
In general following those "checkout this, import that" lists is quite
tedious (and I also started with this JDT list). One reason I use Oomph
most of the time I setup a new workspace.
2. If one is familiar with other Git clients, can they be used instead
of EGit? Or is using EGit mandatory or at least strongly advised?
Egit is especially useful for fetching or pushing changes from/to
Gerrit. But Egit is not mandatory at all and you can use whatever git
client you like. There are also instructions at various places (also
outside of Eclipse project since Gerrit is no Eclipse specialty) how to
push to gerrit with commandline git.
3. Is provisioning Garrit required at any point prior to pushing fixes?
4. At the start of a project, is it best practice or the norm to
create, then work in, a new branch?
If you like. I do most of the time. Just remember (especially if you're
used to the GitHub Pull Request workflow) that changes are provided as
one commit through Gerrit. So you would squash your branch in the end
and provide it as one commit.
Gotta say I'm looking forward to getting a workspace created, especially
if doing so is "ridiculously easy" :-).
platform-dev mailing list
To change your delivery options, retrieve your password, or unsubscribe from
this list, visit