> I have considered everything on my Palm as the 
> Plucker viewer and did not differentiate between 
> the viewer and its pdb file.

It's not correct to say "its pdb file"; the viewer
didn't create the file. The file could be opened by 
any application that is able to read the Plucker 
format (and none of them would be able to jump to 
the "correct" location:)

> When I've written applications for clients in the 
> past, they have never said, "Your data is structured 
> incorrectly", they just say, " Your application does 
> not work correctly".

Sure, but that's not what you said. Remember that you 
tried to be a bit more specific about the problem, 
i.e. you insisted that this was a viewer problem 
although it is the parser that *creates* the Plucker
document.

Also, if you had written a web browser and the client 
complained that it didn't work with a "broken" HTML 
document I don't think you would tell the client "Yes, 
my application doesn't work correctly"; I guess you
instead might tell the client that "Your data is
structured incorrectly" ;-)

> It is often difficult for an end user to determine
> if code or data is at fault when an application
> behaves incorrectly.

Then maybe they should avoid telling the developers
*where* the problem is located and only tell them that
there seems to be a problem ;-)

/Mike


_______________________________________________
plucker-list mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.rubberchicken.org/mailman/listinfo/plucker-list

Reply via email to