I wasn't aware of dump/restore. I need to research that option. It seems
like it is Red Hat utility not easily available for Intrepid. An Ubuntu
GUI application called 'sbackup' is recommended instead. I need to
research sbackup and see if it can sidestep the UUID mismatch that
plagued my tar / backups. 

I wonder if putting the /boot directory on its own partition might help.
I could dd that one tiny partition to avoid the UUID mismatch. The  /
and /home partitions could be backed up any old way. Is there any
minimum size limit for a Linux or Intrepid partition?       

As for the dd requirement of an exactly partition match, until I gain
proficiency in Linux I will only experiment on one machine. Unlike
WindowsXP, Intrepid Linux seems exceeding stable if  I don't screw with
it. So I can use it on other machines that don't see drastic changes.
However I must screw with Linux to learn how it works and how to fix
what I (or eventually others) may break. So one desktop machine is
dedicated to nothing but learning about Linux and I probably won't need
to change the disks as they are new.  

Stability is one reason I migrated to Linux. I can live with having to
fix problems I create in Linux in the learning process. I dislike
Windows problems like registry artifacts that hang around and grow from
old removed applications and other reasons. Backing up a Windows install
usually requires an extra piece of software like Ghost. I'd rather have
an OS that provides all the tools I need. Plus I detest Microsoft's
heavy handed and intrusive software validation process. Windows 2k was
very stable and didn't have the validation regime. I was happy with Win
2k but every release since has gotten less reliable more expensive and
more intrusive and chased me to Linux.

Thanks, 

Word Wizard     




On Thu, 2009-04-16 at 18:36 -0700, Joe Pruett wrote:


> i haven't followed this entire thread, but i have to say that dd is only a 
> useful backup strategy if you will use exactly the same hard disk to 
> restore onto.  using one of a different size or geometry can lead to 
> trouble if the new disk partition isn't sized correctly.  it has to be the 
> same number of sectors or larger, and if larger it won't use the extra 
> space without resizing the filesystem which is another scary operation.
> 
> have you looked at dump/restore?  they produce output that can be stored 
> on disk or tape.  you can also do interactive restores from their images 
> (a mini shell like environment where you can cd and ls and choose files).
> 
> those dump images aren't something that you can just restore and reboot 
> from.  you need to boot into some minimal system (live/rescue cd) and then 
> repartition/reformat/restore.
> 
> if you want a bootable bare metal restore, there are some tools out there 
> that can create bootable cd/dvd disks, but i have never used them.
> _______________________________________________
> PLUG mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://lists.pdxlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/plug
_______________________________________________
PLUG mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.pdxlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/plug

Reply via email to